Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis, IN

Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis, IN

We considered all 176 Property Management Companies in the Indianapolis area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 20.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Indianapolis area.

  • shape-1 176
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 79
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 20
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 20 Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis

Show Map

Alpine Property Management

1848 North Alabama Street Indianapolis, IN 46202

Alpine Property Management is a full-service Indianapolis company currently managing more than 1,000 properties in the Marion County area. Alpine's properties include both homes and apartments, and its full-time property management staff provides simple, straightforward services to tenants, owners and investors. With its experienced team, Alpine is able to perform efficient and thorough screenings of potential tenants. To serve more members of the community, Alpine has can work with Section 8 applicants to provide more affordable housing choices. An online request system makes it simple for tenants to let Alpine know about maintenance requests 24 hours a day, allowing Alpine to respond quickly. All requests are then handled with Alpine's trusted bonded and insured contractors. Both owners and tenants can also make payments using Alpine's convenient online portal. Owners also get access to Alpine's own web-based software to help them track monthly cash flow. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers praise Alpine's quick response times, easy application process and helpful, friendly staff. Other reviewers mention that Alpine was easy to work with when dealing with maintenance requests. One reviewer said "The employees have all been extremely nice and helpful. I've had nothing but a great experience so far."

AMG Property Management

6215 N College Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46220

Adkin Management Group offers property management services in the Indianapolis area. With more than 25 years of rental experience, this family-owned business brings a personal touch to professional property management. The company points to attentive service and total transparency as the reason for its impressive 83% growth over a three-year period. It oversees all aspects of rental investment properties from pre-rent checks to managing leases and advertising vacancies to provide its clients with a continual source of income. Day-to-day maintenance can be left in the capable hands of the AMG team, while major repairs come with multiple quotes and contractor recommendations. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants praise AMG Property Management for their timely response to calls and regular maintenance. Lacey, a tenant with AMG for four years, says, " I've been very pleased with them. We ran into some plumbing trouble... they sent someone out immediately to fix it... They are understanding with payment issues and really responsive to maintenance requests... They even came by and cleaned my gutters last week, without me having to ask."

Barron Property Services

3718 East Michigan Street Indianapolis, IN, 46201

Barron Property Services offers a full range of services to property owners of single and multiple-family residences. It handles owner-approved maintenance and provides expert advice to prospective investors looking to grow their portfolio. In addition to providing professional leasing and brokerage services, this company partners with local contractors, construction firms, and trusted maintenance teams to keep managed properties in good condition. This full-service residential property management company provides investors with thorough monthly and annual reports, brokerage services, renovation oversight, and expert advice on buying and selling properties in the Indianapolis area. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants of properties managed by B.P.S. appreciate the quality of customer service they receive from the staff, who work to help tenants find the home they need at the price they can afford. As one reviewer writes, "Amazing front office staff. They are quick with repairs and are always friendly. I highly recommend this place to rent through. They also help find a place within your price range."

Dorfman Property Management

827 N Capitol Ave Indianapolis, IN 46204

For more than 40 years, Dorfman Property Management has been offering real estate services in the Indianapolis metropolitan area. As a full-service agency, Dorfman coordinates all tasks associated with rental property ownership from responding to letters from the local Home Owners Association to making arrangements to show your property to prospective renters any day of the week. When signing a new landlord client, the first step is a comprehensive inspection, detailing the condition of the property and appliances while documenting any potential problems. The online owners portal allows landlords to quickly gain access to documents and reports surrounding their real estate and set up direct deposit for monthly rent collections. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Property owners rate Dorfman Property Management positively nearly across the board for communication, response times and rapid turnaround times for low vacancy rates. One client said, "I'm a landlord, I have been with Dorfman for over 10 years. Being on the other side of the coin, they treat me great, have great communication, prompt service, and wonderful staff. I couldn't ask for anything more from a property management company." A tenant was pleased to report, "A/C unit motor went out last night at 8 pm and it was approved and fixed by 8 am. All done after hours."

Ethosity Property Management Group

333 N Alabama St #350 Indianapolis, IN 46204

Ethosity Property Management Group provides real estate investors in Indianapolis with a full range of property management services, from initial advertising on new vacancies to finding and attracting new renters. Its staff handles every step of the leasing process such as ongoing communications with tenants. The knowledgeable maintenance team handles initial and annual property inspections, as well as ongoing repairs and emergency maintenance services to keep properties in working order. Clients' finances are managed with professionalism and accuracy, and owners receive detailed reports, including annual and monthly statements, made available through the company's online portal. Investors are never left without a team to rely on in any situation regarding their properties with the expert legal team here that helps with court proceedings and rent collections. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Many renter reviews note Ethosity's dedication to friendly customer service and prompt attention to any issues that arise. One owner also notes the company's attention to tenant satisfaction, "They have been managing our properties for some time now and have been great working with our tenants and helping out problem properties. They come highly recommended!"

Evergrow Property Management

5703 S East Street, Suite A Indianapolis, IN 46227

Evergrow Property Management has served the central Indiana area for over 20 years, providing exceptional management services for all types of residential properties from small homes to multifamily apartment complexes. The professional leasing team takes care of every aspect of the rental process, from initial marketing and advertising of properties to handling move-in and move-out inspections, and all tenant communications in between. A transparent, flat-rate pricing system ensures owners receive the services they need at the price they want. Ongoing care of Indianapolis properties is guaranteed with the firm's extensive network of trusted contractors who provide maintenance and 24-hour on-call services, keeping investments protected through any emergency. Online portals allow tenants to pay rent and request maintenance, and provide owners with easy access to all documents and communications regarding their properties. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Clients and residents appreciate Evergrow Property Management's promptness in finding tenants, and the leasing team's dedication to courtesy. As one reviewer writes, "They have made the transition and the tenant turnover a breeze! I would highly recommend them to any investor with properties in the area."

Gene B. Glick Company

8801 River Crossing Blvd. #200 Indianapolis, IN 46240

Gene B. Glick Company has been providing property management services and housing opportunities for residents of Indiana, as well as twelve other states, since 1947 when it was originally devoted to providing homebuilding opportunities to veterans of the second world war. Real estate investors can expect a full range of services to manage their single-family and multi-family homes, from the construction of new residences through every step of the leasing process. The company appeals to prospective tenants through a wide range of websites and social media strategies. Investors with this group appreciate the thorough tenant screening and background checks, as well as the in-house inspections that are conducted, complete with detailed reports, before and after someone moves in. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers agree that this group is "passionate about delivering a world-class experience to the residents of their communities". Property owners love the advertising campaigns offered by Gene B. Glick, stating the "communications and marketing group are top-notch." This investor goes on to say, "They strikingly standout by far with their intense passion for their communities and residents' satisfaction - which of course is just the best," which is an opinion that's reflected by numerous reviews.

HARVEY Property Management Group

P.O. Box 20803 Indianapolis, Indiana 46220

HARVEY Property Management Group has been serving property owners, investors, and tenants in the Indianapolis area for over 30 years. Owner Harvey Levin and his team have a wealth of professional experience in property management, construction and real estate investing. They offer services including turnkey property management, property setup, property maintenance and construction services. This group can help owners and investors near and far locate likely properties and excellent potential tenants thanks to a full marketing plan for all listings. With expertise in renovation, this team can even help owners make upgrades and repairs to increase the market value of managed properties. Many of HARVEY Property Management Group's clients are investors that may not be local, but technological tools like an online portal, which provides 24-hour account access and real-time cash flow records, help clients easily keep their finances in order. Plus, cloud-based software allows clients to review properties from anywhere. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Clients praise Harvey Property Management for their responsiveness and comprehensive knowledge of the Indianapolis property market. One customer said "We are overseas owners and over several years have found Harvey Levin and his team at Harvey Property helpful, knowledgeable and, an important point, available and responsive to any of our questions."

HomeRiver Group Indianapolis

9100 Keystone Crossing STE 610 Indianapolis, IN 46240

HomeRiver Group Indianapolis offers full-service property management for community associations, residential homes and investment portfolios in the Indianapolis area. The company also offers a full suite of residential real estate services for buyers, sellers, landlords and renters. Owners and renters can go online for free management quotes and rental searches, as well as many other services. Knowledgeable staff members share their experience with clients who are new to investing or new to the area. Investors hire HomeRiver Group to identify new investment opportunities, and the team takes care of everyday details, including tenant placement, application screening applications and inspections. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Long-term and new tenants appreciate the company's superior customer service. Tenants and owners also appreciate the patience and attention to detail of HomeRiver Group Indianapolis staff members. Dreana S. had this to say about her experience, "I recently moved into my home in Indy ... absolutely love my house and the area. Dana was absolutely great and Sherri was awesome too! They both were patient and answered all my questions in the beginning."

Indiana Property Management Group

270 E Carmel Dr. Carmel, IN

Indiana Property Management Group LLC is affiliated with Century 21 Scheetz and has six offices throughout Central Indiana. The firm provides full-service, professional property management services to owners, including thorough application screening. The rules set out by the property owner are respected and the team carefully matches tenants to the right Indiana rentals. When submitting rent payments, maintenance requests and account summaries, tenants can use the company's convenient online tenant portal. Owners and investors gain the advantages of working with a team of consummate professionals familiar with property management in the central Indiana region. The trained and licensed property managers deal fairly and act with integrity when representing their clients. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Long-time client Zach H. praise the team's consistent customer service, saying, "We've worked with quite a few PMs over the years and Jason, Meredith and the team at IPM are by far the best. They have great communication and follow through and always have our best interests in mind. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a property manager in Indy."

IndyFlippers

8070 Castleton Rd. Indianapolis, IN 46250

IndyFlippers is dedicated to providing top-tier property management and investment rehab services to investors in the Indianapolis area and has an A+ BBB rating. Property owners enjoy a wide range of services that are tailored to their specific needs and automated for convenience. All aspects of leasing are handled by the company's professional staff. In particular, a wide range of services is offered including property staging and repairs, advertising, tenant screening and preparing lease documents. Tenants can access the online portal at any time to pay rent and request maintenance, and payments are automatically deposited into the owner's bank accounts. Monthly and annual statements are provided to investors during tax time and upon request at any other time during the year, and any services charged to investors' accounts are itemized and transparent, with no upcharges. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Online reviewers agree that the services offered by IndyFlippers are of high quality and are provided by a friendly team that cares about their tenants and clients. As one tenant writes, the staff "always addressed any issues or concerns I had in a timely and effective manner. If you're looking for a property management company that truly cares, as well as quality rental properties, IndyFlippers is where you should go."

Kline Properties, Inc.

1910 E Washington St Ste B Indianapolis, IN 46201

Serving Indianapolis and the surrounding communities since 2001, Kline Properties offers a full portfolio of property management services to real estate investors with properties in the area. Owners can relax while Kline takes care of all aspects of the leasing process, from putting properties on the market with a wide range of outlets to attracting prospective tenants to the creation and signing of leases and ongoing communications with tenants. Initial and annual inspections are completed by their in-house maintenance crew, and all rents and security deposits are handled with automatic monthly deposits made to property owners' accounts. Low setup fees and transparent billing keep investors from overpaying for services. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Online reviewers agree that this company provides all the services they need to manage their properties from Indianapolis or abroad. As one investor writes, "The best part is that they are a one-stop-shop for all real estate management needs for any out of area investors such as myself. They can even . . . pay taxes and mortgages on the property owner's behalf. "

PMI Indianapolis Property Management, Inc.

7275 N. Shadeland Ave. Suite 2 Indianapolis, IN 4625

PMI Property Management's Indianapolis office provides a full range of services to those in need of property management in the area. Their team of dedicated real estate professionals lends their experience to residential and commercial property owners, as well as assisting in homeowners associations and real estate deals. Interested property owners can take advantage of this company's free online rental analysis tool to learn about their property value on the current market, and to see what services this company can provide them. Handling both single-family and multi-family homes, this group provides help every step of the way, from marketing properties to finding and screening tenants. All ongoing communications are handled by their friendly office team, and residents can quickly pay their rent on time using the secure online portal. Owners appreciate the portal for instant access to all of their property documents and financial records, as well as tenant information. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Owners and residents rave about this company's dedication to customer service. As one recent customer stated in an online review, "We just completed a portfolio migration to PMI-Midwest and the execution was flawless! All units transitioned with 100% of rent paid and posted on time. The PMI staff is highly professional, delivering great communication and support to me as an owner and to the residents. The reporting on the PMI portal illuminates everything!"

Polaris Property Management

5455 W 86th St Suite 123 Indianapolis, IN 46268

Polaris Property Management is an award-winning company that manages residential properties throughout the Indianapolis area. It offers a full spectrum of management services including comparative market analysis to determine appropriate rental prices, rent collection and repair and maintenance coordination. The company uses a wide range of resources to market properties and its tenant screening procedures are among the most comprehensive in the industry. Tenants can use the online portal to pay rent and submit maintenance requests, while landlords can log in to view and manage income reports and communicate with the company. Polaris Property Management is a member of the National Association of Realtors and the Indiana Association of Realtors. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants and landlords alike consistently speak highly of Polaris Property Management's professionalism and communication. Tenants are frequently pleased with the company's speediness when it comes to repairs. One landlord states, "Dan and Polaris took over my units and completely turned them around. He is extremely knowledgeable and prompt. I have never worked with a more professional group. His team is always making sure things are done the right way."

Sheehan Property Management

6930 Atrium Boardwalk S Indianapolis, IN 46250

Sheehan Property Management provides exceptional residential management services to real estate holders in the Indianapolis area, as well as the Columbus and Louisville areas. Its team of certified leasing agents uses the financial expertise they've gained from over 100 years of combined experience. The firm maximizes profits and provides consultation and management services for new construction investors. With a focus on multi-family housing, this investment firm works with local businesses to create all-inclusive apartment communities. These hybrid buildings give residents access to unique opportunities to enjoy luxurious amenities. Prospective tenants love the new residential, office, retail, and dining spaces these innovative spaces combine into one innovative community. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Renters and owners appreciate that, even though this large firm has several offices, they still feel valued as local clients with the highest levels of customer service both in house and in over the phone communications. As one reviewer writes, "The management team is very supportive and the corporate office cares about you and values your opinions."

T&H Realty Services

760 E. 52nd Street Indianapolis, IN, 46205

T&H Realty Services offers full-service, white-glove property management to the right clients. This company limits landlord applicants to those with small properties — typically single-family homes or multi-family properties with no more than four units — where each unit rents for at least $1,000 per month. To help meet those goals, the first step in a management agreement with T&H Realty Services is often a pre-leasing evaluation with a market analysis to determine any reasonable upgrades that may maximize the potential rents on a property. If T&H agrees to represent a property, landlord's get a unique tenant screening process that is so thorough the company advertises a less than 1% eviction rate per year. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers comment on the ease of communication and exceptional expertise provided by T&H Realty. Jason A., said, "I am an out of state SFH owner/investor and was having a very poor experience with a different provider. I contacted T&H on a recommendation and I could not be happier. The onboarding, communication, and reporting have all been on point." Another client was pleased that a small upgrade investment resulted in a solid income increase on the advice of T&H staff.

TBH Management

6028 N Keystone Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46220

TBH Management helps Indianapolis real estate investors manage their single-family homes, townhouses, condos, HOAs and apartments. The company is dedicated to using the latest technologies to provide the highest standard of service. Property owners have easy online access to all documents, photos, inspections and financial reports via the company's convenient online portal. Tenants can utilize the portal to pay their rent on time and request maintenance services. Serving the Indianapolis area for over 12 years, this established leader in the local market is headed by a team of certified property managers and holds membership with the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and Certified Apartment Management (CAM) designation in addition to its Indiana state real estate licensing. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

"I have rented with them for 6 years now and I've not had any issues. When I've needed maintenance, it has always been handled professionally and timely. If I have questions, I can always call the office and I know my questions will be answered. The ladies in the office are great to work with," raves one online reviewer, who agrees with the general consensus that the staff here are friendly as well as efficient.

Triple E Property Management

1075 Broad Ripple Ave #136 Indianapolis, IN 46220

Triple E Property Management has ten years of experience providing assistance to property owners and investors in the Indianapolis area. This company is dedicated to ensuring their clients are never surprised by fees and provides a schedule of charges on their website. It offers a full range of services to help property managers get their units rented, from initial property evaluation through tenant screening and ongoing communications. As well as high-quality property management services for single-family and multi-family homes, this company contracts with a network of trusted carpenters and other service professionals to help owners with needed repairs and renovation projects. The company also offers a convenient and secure online portal, where tenants can pay their rent on time and request maintenance. Owners love the portal due to its easy access to their property documents and financial statements. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Owners and tenants alike agree that this company provides excellent customer service and has a speedy repair process. As one online reviewer recently wrote, they are "Extremely happy with this company! They always respond, always take care of what needs to be done. Communication has been excellent. Very honest and trustworthy. [I] wish we had found them sooner. Great people to work with and I highly recommend them."

USI Property Management

215 W Edwards Ave Indianapolis, IN 46217

USI Property Management in Indianapolis provides quality housing options to locals and a full range of property management services for owners. The company helps owners prepare their properties for new tenants, and markets them through a wide range of outlets to help find the right tenant quickly. Owners don't have to worry about lease preparation, inspections or ongoing communications from tenants, with the USI team handling all these aspects of leasing. Tenants are able to pay their rent online and request maintenance services through the handy portal, while owners can use the portal to read about the status of their properties and any communications from their management team. This company also provides ongoing 24-hour emergency maintenance of their client's investments. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Long-term owners value the consistency and trust they have with this real estate team at USI. As one owner recently wrote online, they manage properties "in an exemplary manner with a focus on treating our tenants with the respect they deserve while protecting our assets and interests in a prompt time-frame. We have been very pleased with the company's performance and diligence."

We Manage Indy

6330 E 75th St #150 Indianapolis, IN 46250

The property managers at We Manage Indy provides a full portfolio of services to single-family homeowners and multi-family property owners in the central Indiana area. The experts here help investors with modeling and rehab work on older homes to prepare their properties for new tenants, as well as implement new construction projects. We Manage Indy helps bring in a wide variety of quality tenants looking for a new home by preparing an advertising campaign for their managed properties that entices new tenants from many corners of the local market, with local and national outlets. The friendly leasing team here handles all tenant screening and background checks, as well as lease preparation and all ongoing communications throughout their tenancy. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants appreciate how friendly the staff is, with online reviewers agreeing We Manage Indy's team of office staff and leasing agents are "Professional and quick to respond." Both renters and real estate investors alike love the online portal for finding the right home as well as paying rent and requesting maintenance with ease, helping ensure investments are well taken care of.

Property Management in Nearby Cities