Best Property Management Companies in Columbus, OH

Best Property Management Companies in Columbus, OH

We considered all 220 Property Management Companies in the Columbus area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 27.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Columbus area.

  • shape-1 220
    Facilities Reviewed
  • shape-1 99
    Facilities Curated
  • shape-1 27
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 27 Best Property Management Companies in Columbus

Show Map

Access More Realty & Property Management

4102 Anson Drive Hillard, OH 43026

Access More Realty & Property Management was founded in 2017 by an owner with over 28 years of industry experience in the Columbus area. The family-owned-and-operated company specializes in helping investors revitalize distressed properties and promoting underserved areas and Section 8 housing. The managers use aggressive marketing plans to list each property across major search websites and carefully screen potential tenants. They also keep careful tabs on each property, performing routine maintenance as needed. Owners and tenants both have access to portals that allow real-time account management, online rent payments, and maintenance requests. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers have been thrilled with what Access Moore Real Estate & Property Management can accomplish for their investments and how well the operation has been run. A customer shared, “Access More Realty is the BEST. The staff is wonderful and professional! Antonio D'Alberto is heaven sent! He was the best property manager I have ever dealt with!! You can't go wrong having him on your team. He's a home run hitter.”

Advanced Realty Management Inc.

5350 East Livingston Ave Hillard, OH 43232

Advanced Realty Management Inc. was officially incorporated in 1988 and has served the Columbus area with property management, HOA management, and real estate services ever since. It takes great pride in being one of the first real estate companies in Columbus to incorporate computers and technology into daily operations. The team ensures that homes are in an acceptable condition prior to entering into a contract with a homeowner and goes to great lengths to ensure that they stay up to par. As part of its property management services, Advanced Realty Management performs quarterly inspections on every property in its portfolio, requesting maintenance as necessary. Other services include tenant screening, rental marketing, rent collection, online payment system, and customer communications. The company’s goal is to manage each property as efficiently as possible while maintaining a personal touch with each customer ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for Advanced Realty Management Inc

Beacon Property Management

807 East Broad Street Columbus, OH 43205

Beacon Property Management has specialized in all kinds of property management services since 1988, with over 1,000 units in its portfolio. It keeps a full-time maintenance crew on staff to assist with monthly inspections, common area maintenance, emergency needs, and specialized services, such as HVAC. The leasing team manages pre-screening of tenants, annual rent increases, and delivery of late fees and eviction notices. Reports are delivered monthly to owners, including rental statements, occupancy rates, turnover reports, and budgets. Up-to-date information on available units is kept on the company website with accurate pictures. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Beacon Property Management has established long-time relationships with countless clients, who all rave about the attention to detail and timely responses to maintenance requests. A five-star reviewer and multi-year customer shared their experience: “Beacon Property has managed my rental unit for the past 6 years and I couldn't be more pleased with their service and support. [...] They are quick to respond to our tenants and provide maintenance. Our property manager, Brian, keeps in frequent contact with me. When releasing the property he works diligently to show the property and screen potential tenants — leaving us with minimal vacancy time and lost income.”

Borror

95 North High Street #200 Columbus, OH 43201

For over 60 years, Borror has served the Columbus area with apartment, HOA, and senior living management, as well as construction services and real estate sales. As a property manager, the company strives to protect the investment of the owner down to the smallest detail. Borror has a maintenance staff on hand 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year, ensuring that no issue is overlooked or dropped through the cracks. The company assumes full responsibility for sales, marketing, and expense planning for capital improvements. It also prioritizes premier properties in high demand communities ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Borror strives to be the leader in improving communities across Columbus and works hard to set the bar high for honest, dependable service. One Google reviewer shared, “I love Borror and what they stand for. Honest, dependable, and forever improving to make life better for all … I strongly recommend Borror for all of your management, construction, and development desires!”

Columbus Best Rentals

2266 ½ East Main Street East Columbus, OH 43209

Columbus Best Rentals provides rental homes and property management services at affordable rates. The company offers a wide variety of rental homes with different lease options. Renters have options to purchase select rental properties at the end of their lease term. Columbus Best Rentals has strict showing and renter policies to ensure that they are protecting the investment of their owner clients ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for Columbus Best Rentals.

Columbus Realty Source

3886 North High Street Columbus, OH 43214

Columbus Realty Source was established in 1998 with the goal of providing high-quality real estate and property management services to the Columbus area. It is intimately familiar with each area of the local market and caters its services for the individual needs of each property. The team handles all day-to-day details of each property, including marketing, maintenance, and rent collection. The company recently invested in high-tech software that allows it to more efficiently manage each property. Once a unit becomes available, Columbus Realty Source can update its internal system and instantly share the details on hundreds of property search engines, and its rental comparison tool lets the management team effectively price each unit for faster turnaround times. The software also lets tenants make online rent payments and filter maintenance requests and provides up-to-the-minute account statements to property owners. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers have come to expect a higher level of service from Columbus Realty Source and know that their home will be taken care of each and every day. A customer shared on Google that they are “the best landlords I've had since living in Columbus for nearly 10 years. Brittany was always quick with correspondence whenever I had a question or concerns, and the turn around rate for maintenance issues was always fast. Managers made sure the public areas of the property were aesthetically pleasing and neat, and they were on top of fixing/updating features of the building. Rent was very reasonable considering the area that I lived in ...”

Core Select Property Group

1355 King Avenue Columbus, OH 43212

Core Select Property Group was founded in 2018 as a sister company to Core Ohio, Inc. in an effort to better serve the needs of its real estate investment customers. It supports the management needs of several hundred properties in the Columbus area. Each unit is advertised on hundreds of rental search sites for optimum visibility. Services include rent collection, maintenance, marketing, leasing, renewals, and tax preparation, as well as portals for both owners and tenants. These can be accessed both online and via an app and allow customers to view statements, pay rent, and request maintenance ...Read More

What customers are saying:

As a boutique company, Core Select Property Group can focus on the individual needs of each property owner, allowing them to feel valued. Customers have been thrilled with the service they receive and the results their investments achieve. One investor shared, “Core Ohio manages our scattered site portfolio, which has been trending at 100% occupancy since taking over management. Core Ohio utilizes advanced technology in order to achieve maximum efficiency. As a property owner, my husband and I have a high level of comfort with Core Ohio managing our properties. We would highly recommend Core Ohio to other property owners.”

Elford Realty

1220 Dublin Road Columbus, OH 43215

Elford Realty was founded in 2000 to provide management services for its development partners. The company uses its large market presence and buying power to help its owner clients achieve lower operating costs and higher returns on their investments. As a residential property manager, Elford Realty works with multi-family projects and homeowners associations. It specializes in helping owners find creative marketing strategies to fill vacancies in their properties. The managers commit to frequent communication with property owners, keeping them informed of all important details ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Elford Realty goes above and beyond to help owners find the right investment properties. A customer shared on Google, “I am amazed at the level of service provided by Andy at Elford! Want to see what is available, and also what isn't but is exactly what you want? They contacted a bunch of building owners near the locations I wanted, and found some great, non listed properties! They told me they would work hard, but they really proved it too. I would suggest working with Elford.”

Full Circle Property Management

1695 Old Henderson Road Columbus, OH 43220

Full Circle Property Management, formerly Rickert Management, has served the Columbus area since 1986 with some of the most experienced staff members in the industry. It manages over 400 apartments and individual home units, as well as a mix of commercial properties and homeowner’s associations. The company employs a full-time maintenance crew to assist with basic repairs and emergency needs on weekends or after-hours. Property management staff will research a property thoroughly to determine an appropriate monthly rate and actively seek out qualified tenants. Property owners have access to an online portal that has real-time reports on property income and expenses. Full Circle has a guaranteed tenant fee, meaning that it will discount its fees on the next tenant if the current one does not stay for the entire lease term. The company also operates as a full-service real estate brokerage so as to assist customers with the buying and selling of future investment properties as well. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers of Full Circle Property Management feel good knowing that any issues that come up will be handled both efficiently and professionally, leaving all parties satisfied. One long-time tenant recently shared, “I have had no issues that they were not able to fully come to a resolution on. Minor repairs and such have been done both quickly and professionally … I would recommend them to both rent from and manage a property if I owned one.”

Golden Gate Real Estate

573 Carle Ave Lewis Center, OH 43035

Golden Gate Real Estate is a full-service brokerage firm that has offered property management services since 2005. It specializes in single-family homes, multi-family homes, commercial properties, retail, and office buildings. Services include leasing, marketing, tenant placement, maintenance, rent collections, and evictions. By offering full real estate management, Golden Gate is able to assist investors with the acquisition of a property, its maintenance, and then the sale when the time comes. Customers can diversify their investment portfolios as much or as little as needed. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers across all divisions of real estate appreciate the personal service they receive from Golden Gate Real Estate. A customer who has worked with the company many times shared, “I have done several deals with this company over many years. They are nothing but professional and knowledgeable. My company purchases several hundred properties per year and have dealt with many companies all over the country but this company is among the best.”

KBK Enterprises

4249 Easton Way #220 Columbus, OH 43219

KBK Enterprises was founded in 2004 in an effort for the owner to take their development and housing skills to a nationwide level, and they opened the property management division, Key Property Management Services, in 2010. The company attributes its success to its multi-faceted approach of working with clients, owners, and renters as a team to assess the individual needs of each property. It approaches management issues with the foresight of what will improve the future resale of the property, as well as what would be the best for the community. KBK Enterprises specializes in the reporting practices mandated by government agencies such as HUD. Property management services include file management, reporting, and collections. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for KBK Enterprises.

Kohr Royer Griffith

1480 Dublin Road Columbus, OH 43215

Founded in 1914, Kohr Royer Griffith (KRG) has served the Columbus area for over 100 years as one of the oldest property management companies in the area. The company has been at the forefront of technological advances in the industry, being among the first to implement new marketing strategies and management practices. KRG is affiliated with organizations such as Building and Owners and Managers Association, the Institute for Real Estate Management, and the Columbus Apartment Association. Services include rent collection, accounting and reporting, capital improvement planning, budgeting, leasing and marketing, tenant relations, and maintenance with both in-house and third-party contractors ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Kohr Royer Griffith works hard to provide the best value for the area while providing affordable housing with great service. Tenants know they can expect to be treated fairly and for their buildings to be kept up nicely. A reviewer shared, “They are the one of the best responsive maintenance team for older apartments and very clean … it’s very best value as an apartment rental company for your buck.”

Legacy Management Services

266 Chittenden Ave Columbus, OH 43201

Legacy Management Services was founded in 2005 and is a growing company that specializes in the management of off-campus student housing. As industry experts, Legacy Management not only offers full-service management but also industry advice about market rates, tax issues, and growth and development. Services for property owners include advertising, showings, applicant screening, lease preparation, inspections, rent collection, maintenance, move-in/out cleanouts, and accounting and bookkeeping services. Online portals are available for tenants to make rent payments and request maintenance service, as well as for owners to see up-to-date statements. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Most customers of Legacy Management Services are busy students whose housing needs are completely met by LMS, and reviewers are thrilled with the service they receive. A grad student reviewed LMS online, saying: “The process was very painless and the company is very flexible. Yes, things break every now and then, but their maintenance and management has always went above and beyond to make sure it is addressed. [...] I can tell you I am somewhat of a difficult and particular tenant at times, LMS knows how to take care of you.”

Myers Real Estate

1221 Grandview Avenue Columbus, OH 43212

Myers Real Estate has been owned and operated by the Myers family since 1937. Its property management services are individually catered to each customer, and experienced staff is dedicated to each property to ensure its success. Myers takes all the hassles out of management and provides an answering service and online rent payments, applications, and maintenance requests. Online listings are kept up to date, with professional photography to help them stand out. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Myers Real Estate treats all customers like family and ensures that each property is cared for as if it was owned by the company itself. Owners and tenants can expect calls and maintenance requests to be handled quickly. One property owner recently shared on Google, “Our overall experience was very positive; if there was a problem with anything on the property, Myers provided us with estimates and lists of general contractors to get them fixed. [...] They always provided us with a detailed monthly cost sheet and also provided us with tenant information about back costs and rent not being paid. Lastly when we chose to sell the property their real estate broker helped us acquire and sell the home.”

Northpoint Asset Management

470 Olde Worthington, Suite 200 Westerville, OH 43082

Northpoint Asset Management is a nation-wide company with over 30 years of property management industry experience. It utilizes advanced software to market properties and generate the highest traffic possible. The leasing process includes marketing, tenant screening, and move-in inspections. Throughout the lease term, Northpoint will inspect the property frequently to stay on top of any preventative maintenance and ensure that the tenants are treating the property with care. The hands-on managers work to secure the best prices for maintenance and subcontractors in order to save owners as much money as possible. Northpoint also has an online portal where tenants can pay their rent and request maintenance, and owners can see real-time performance statements of each of their properties ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers are thrilled with the personal service they receive from the property managers at Northpoint Asset Management and are particularly happy with how quickly their properties lease out. A customer shared, “We are currently leasing our property which is being managed by Kat Rosas and she has been an absolute pleasure to work with. She is an amazing professional and has done everything in her power to ensure our specific needs are met. She had excellent judgment on finding good tenants and ensures they are well taken care of. I would happily recommend her to anyone looking for any property management needs!”

Northwood Properties, Inc

3145 North High Street Columbus, OH 43202

Northwood Properties, Inc has provided affordable rental properties in the Columbus area since 1994. It was founded on the idea that it is difficult to find a competent management team that truly cares about the renter’s wellbeing. Northwood ensures that all properties are well looked after and that regular maintenance and renovations take place as needed. On the website, there is a tenant portal that allows renters to pay for their bills and request maintenance ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers of Northwood Properties, Inc. report that the staff is patient and accommodating and that their needs are met promptly. A reviewer shared, “I worked with Drew and found the perfect apartment for myself in Columbus. All units that we looked at were in great condition, new floors, very clean/well maintained and in a great location. Working with Northwood Properties was easy as they were fast to respond and very helpful with making the transition. If I ever need to find another apartment in Columbus again, I will be doing it with Northwood.”

Oakwood Management Company

6950 Americana Pkwy A Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Oakwood Management Company manages over 8,000 apartment units in the Columbus area and is one of the largest management companies in central Ohio. It is a member of the Columbus Apartment Association and an Accredited Management Organization. Oakwood focuses on three key points: kindness, efficiency, and quality. The company aims to protect the investment of its clients so they are proud of whom they chose to do business with. Oakwood has negotiated several perks for residents, including discounts at various golf courses, and offers discounts on rent and/or deposits for teachers and service members. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants of an Oakwood Management Company community know that they can go home feeling safe and appreciated on a daily basis. Reviews across the web show tenants with multi-year leases because they enjoy the management so much. One renter shared, “I am staying here from last 2 years and very nice community and friendly office staff. Whenever I reach office staff for an issue, they take immediate action and close the issue on the same day or next day for sure. Very nice Maintenance team and works after hours too if issue is there and until the issue fixed, they will not leave it. I feel happy & secure staying in the community.”

Panzera Realty

896 King Avenue Columbus, OH 43212

Panzera Realty has served the Columbus area with a full range of real estate and property management services since 1995 and has a portfolio of over 300 units. Its licensed professionals possess a deep knowledge of the market and can easily help property owners buy and sell properties to expand their personal portfolios, find and screen tenants, and perform maintenance and repairs as necessary. As a local company, Panzera performs frequent property visits and meets with customers in a timely fashion in the office or on property. The firm is run by people who own their own investment properties, so they understand the unique needs and issues that may arise with trying to manage rental homes. Renters can apply for housing, fill out maintenance requests, and manage their individual accounts on the company website ...Read More

What customers are saying:

When Panzera Realty assumes management of a property, owners know their investments will be well cared for and issues will be resolved in a timely fashion. A reviewer shared their experience and how great Panzera was to work with: “David and his team did a fantastic job managing my rental property. They took over and helped me resolve numerous issues left by my previous property management company. David always responded quickly with answers. I would recommend using Panzera Realty for property management. I was very pleased and satisfied using their services.”

Peak Property Group

1646 North High Street Columbus, OH 43201

Peak Property Group was founded in 2009 as a property acquisition group and has since expanded its services to include property and asset management. The company takes great pride in its A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and works with its customers to maximize the potential of each investment property. Its management portfolio includes more than $150 million in multi-family communities. Services include leasing and marketing, tenant screening, renewals, preventative maintenance, 24/7 emergency maintenance, vendor and subcontractor management, renovation management, and in-depth financial reporting. Residents of the communities can log into the company website to make rent payments and contact their apartment management. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Leasing from Peak Property Group means that the resident can count on friendly service and prompt responses to any requests. One former tenant shared on Google, “Peak Property is definitely at the top of the list of all the property managers with which I've had to engage. They are very accessible and accommodating. I'm glad that they are reliable and they keep their properties in tip-top condition. I had a very pleasant leasing experience. I am very grateful to have been a tenant with them.”

Realty Executives Central

4701 Olentangy River Road #204 Columbus, OH 43214

Realty Executives Central is a fully functioning property management and brokerage firm that has been locally owned and operated since 1992. It currently manages over 600 properties, ranging from single-family homes to condos and multi-family complexes. The company maintains over a 95% occupancy rate, with 40% of the units representing single-family homes and the remaining larger properties. Its services include advertising, showing, leasing, tenant screening, tenant relations, maintenance, evictions, collections, and bill payment. Tenants can pay rent and make maintenance requests on the company website. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Those who rent from Realty Executives Central know they can count on the management team to take care of any issues that arise. A long-time customer shared on Yelp, “As a landlord I've nothing but good experiences, repairs made quickly, the lease is legit, and no rush to hike up the rent everytime I renew.”

Renting Ohio

8889 Commerce Loop Drive Columbus, OH 43240

Renting Ohio was founded in 2006 and has quickly become one of the fastest-growing property management companies in Ohio. Some of its 700% growth over a year can be attributed to the use of a high-tech software system. The software helps managers accurately price a rental and then post the listing across hundreds of search sites for the highest possible visibility. Property statements are available on-demand, and residents and owners can even use the software to request maintenance. Renting Ohio is affiliated with ReMax and will help property owners buy and sell investment homes to further diversify their portfolio. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for Renting Ohio

RL Property Management Group

753 East Broad Street Columbus, OH 43205

RL Property Management Group (RLPMG) has bought and managed investment properties since 2008. It has a team of dedicated property managers, not realtors, to serve the needs of clients and tenants. The company has created a unique system that allows it to attract and retain long-term tenants and has an over 70% renewal rate. It specializes in single-family homes and small to medium-sized apartment buildings. As a full-service management company, RLPMG handles all day-to-day business, such as maintenance calls, tenant communication, leasing, marketing, and security. Property owners have online portals to check real-time account statements and maintenance calls. RLPMG is affiliated with Angie's List, Olde Towne East, the National Association of Residential Property Managers, and Thumbtack Professionals ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Clients and tenants are both extremely happy with all that RL Property Management Group has to offer and how their expectations are always exceeded. The company knows that customer service and efficient communication are key to growing the business. A long-time property owner shared a Google review: “R&L has managed my rental properties for several years ... Along with the monthly reports they send out, it's easy to log-in to see even more detail about each repair, etc, if desired. If a property needs extensive work done, they provide plenty of photos documenting the problem and try to offer more than one repair option. Peter and Adam both respond quickly to any inquiries ... and are serious about doing a good, professional job ..

SBS Management LLC

4872 Cemetery Road Hillard, OH 43026

SBS Management LLC was founded over a decade ago and now manages several dozen single-family homes, condo associations, and commercial buildings in the greater Columbus area. The privately held company works hard to meet the individual needs of each client. Services include accounting, financial reporting, soft collections, routine maintenance, tenant communication and newsletters, and periodic inspections. SBS Property Management updated its website to make it easier for prospective clients to seek services. It is affiliated with the Better Business Bureau, the Community Associations Institute, the National Federation of Independent Businesses, and the HACC. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for SBS Management LLC

Smith Tandy Group

536 South Wall Street #300 Columbus, OH 43215

Smith Tandy Group is a privately held real estate company offering property management services, acquisitions, construction supervision, and portfolio management. The goal of the company is to “do it all” with turnkey services, from development to management. Its management portfolio currently spans apartment complexes and senior living complexes. Smith Tandy Group also allows online payments and offers referral fees and discounts ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for Smith Tandy Group.

Solutions for Real Estate

1103 Schrock Road, #103 Columbus, OH 43229

Solutions for Real Estate has served Ohio with its “Find It, Fix It, Fill It” methods since 2001. The company’s team of expert realtors will help any investor find their next property to quickly grow their portfolio. Prior to renting the property out, the team will thoroughly inspect it, make any necessary repairs, and then search for highly qualified tenants so the investor's wealth will continue to grow over time. The company believes that communication and integrity are key to a successful business and so speaks with property owners several times during the ownership and rental process. Owners can access an online portal with up-to-date account statements and communication from the staff. Residents can also use an online account to request maintenance service ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Both owners and tenants alike have taken notice of how Solutions for Real Estate pays attention to every little detail when taking care of the property. One customer who has several properties with Solutions for Real Estate shared that they “have been incredibly pleased with the service they provide. From the staff interactions with us as homeowners, to the way they work to ensure the tenants' needs are met, to the systems they have in place to ensure everything is running smoothly — top notch!”

The Bray Co

135 Allview Road Westerville, OH 43081

The Bray Co. was founded nearly two decades ago when the owner broke from a competing company to find a way to provide personalized and cost-conscious property management services. It has grown to manage over 3,000 apartment units and 1,000 single-family homes. The company’s goal is to work with both investors and tenants as a team to achieve the best service at the most affordable prices. Residents of Bray Co. properties are able to pay rent online, as well as request maintenance ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are currently no reviews available for The Bray Co

Wallace F. Ackley Company

2159 Maple Bend Columbus, OH 43229

Wallace F. Ackley Company has been serving the real estate needs of the Columbus area for over 80 years. Its management portfolio spans over 2,400 units that range from apartments to single-family homes and commercial space. It holds an Accredited Management designation and is affiliated with the National Association of Realtors, the Columbus Board of Realtors, the Institute of Real Estate Management, the Building Association of Central Ohio, the Columbus Apartment Association, and the Columbus Chamber of Commerce. There are various tenant resources on the company website, such maintenance requests and lease applications ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers who rent from Wallace F. Ackley Company have come to expect prompt responses to their needs. One long-time customer shared, “I have rented my apartment from Wallace F. Ackley Co. for the past five years. Their service has consistently been high-quality; they have always been responsive to my needs.”

Property Management in Nearby Cities