The Best Property Management Companies in Fort Myers, Florida of 2022

The Best Property Management Companies in Fort Myers, Florida of 2022

We considered all 240 Property Management Companies in the Fort Myers area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 25.

The Best Property Management Companies in Fort Myers, Florida of 2022

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Fort Myers area.

  • shape-1 240
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 108
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 25
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    An extensive track record of reliable, honest service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Understands property laws and industry best practices.

  • 3. Experience

    Knowledge of your property to save you time and money.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Provides transparent, fair pricing and great communication.

The 25 Best Property Management Companies in Fort Myers

Show Map
All County Medallion Property Management
239-204-4171 Click to Call Visit Site

All County Medallion Property Management

2726 Oak Ridge Court, Suite 501 Fort Myers, FL 33901

All County Medallion Property Management is a full-service property management company that offers services to both property owners and buyers or tenants in Southwest Florida. The firm offers personalized management services, which include everything from rental property evaluation and marketing of rental properties to rent collection and lease renewals. It specializes in maximizing rental property revenue and charges transparent fees so property owners aren't caught by surprise by unexpected bills. The company is a member of The Royal Palm Coast Chapter of The National Association of Realtors. ...Read More

Anchor Property Services
239-994-4678 Click to Call Visit Site

Anchor Property Services

8595 College Parkway, #350 Fort Myers, FL 33919

With a combined experience of over six decades, the team of real estate agents at Anchor Property Services focuses on creating solid returns on investments. To help property owners maximize their income potential, the company verifies the market rents on a monthly basis and offers a discount system for tenants who pay early to minimize collection efforts. Other services provided by Anchor Property Services include quality tenant selection and in-house maintenance to keep expenses as low as possible. For tenants, the company provides 24-hour maintenance and real-time online statement access. ...Read More

Basora Investment Group LLC
239-245-9255 Click to Call Visit Site

Basora Investment Group LLC

2400 First Street, Suite 305 Fort Myers FL, 33901

A property management company based in Fort Myers, Basora Investment Group LLC focuses on the management of homes, townhomes and condos in multiple areas that include Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Bonita Springs, Lehigh Acres, Punta Gorda and Naples. The team has years of experience with the local property market and provides full management services that range from marketing and tenant screening to maintenance and accounting. It covers both annual and vacation rentals and specializes in homes for sale. Julia Basora, the founder of the company, has over 16 years of experience in real estate business. ...Read More

Blue Bear Property Management
844-736-8239 Click to Call Visit Site

Blue Bear Property Management

24301 Walden Center Drive, Suite 300 Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Blue Bear Property Management is a fully licensed, insured and bonded property management company in Bonita Springs that is locally owned and operated. The team understands that every property is unique and provides each property owner with customizable property management solutions to maximize investments. With a 24/7 online portal access, owners can have easy access to all the monthly statements and have all the information about repairs and bills at their fingertips. Tenants also benefit from online solutions for paying rent and requesting repairs. Blue Bear Property Management finds qualified tenants and handles showings, lease signing, reference checks and move-in and move-out inspections. ...Read More

Boback Commercial Group
239-466-7770 Click to Call Visit Site

Boback Commercial Group

10501 Ben C.Pratt/Six Mile Cypress Parkway, Suite 104 Fort Myers, FL 3396

Boback Commercial Group provides property management solutions for commercial clients in the South Florida area. All the members of the company's team are experienced in commercial real estate sales and leasing, and they can provide assistance with everything from retail and office to industrial and medical real estate solutions. The company focuses on providing commercial customers with personalized solutions for property sale or lease. Specializing in both commercial buildings and land real estate, Boback Commercial Group is affiliated with the Real Estate Investment Society. ...Read More

Country Club Rentals, Inc.
239-425-0966 Click to Call Visit Site

Country Club Rentals, Inc.

8961 Daniels Center Drive, Suite 407 Fort Myers, FL 33912

Focusing on premiere properties in the Fort Myers and surrounding areas, Country Club Rentals, Inc., offers assistance with both vacation and long-term rentals. The highly experienced team uses a sound knowledge of the local area to pair tenants and buyers with suitable properties for their needs. The company also offers property management services for homeowners who don't want to go through the hassle of finding tenants on their own. Property management services include marketing the property online, vetting prospective tenants, collecting rent and dealing with all repairs and maintenance. ...Read More

Hampton Properties & Consulting, Inc.
239-340-9344 Click to Call Visit Site

Hampton Properties & Consulting, Inc.

12021 Flintlock Lane Fort Myers, FL 33912

Hampton Properties & Consulting, Inc., is a property management company that has been offering its services to Florida residents for 25 years. Focusing on maximizing profits for investors, the company handles all aspects of property leasing and management, from sourcing quality tenants and performing background and financial checks to collecting rent and handling evictions as needed. Led by William H. Floyd, the team at Hampton Properties & Consulting, Inc., puts an emphasis on customer service and prides itself in having less than 1% vacancy for the properties they manage. ...Read More

HomeRiver Group
941-487-1538 Click to Call Visit Site

HomeRiver Group

12906 Tampa Oaks Blvd. Ste 100, Temple Terrace, FL 33637

HomeRiver Group has shown that they know how to maintain high levels of tenant satisfaction. This provider's maintenance response team is available 24/7 to fix any issues that pop up, and their online platform makes it especially easy for tenants to submit rental payments. Overall, they will help you reduce vacancies and generate more rental income. ...Read More

Incore Residential
239-275-8320 Click to Call Visit Site

Incore Residential

3414 Forum Boulevard, #3 Fort Myers, FL 33905

Incore Residential is a company in Fort Myers that has been providing property management services in Southwest Florida since 1999. Focusing on multifamily management, the team strives to increase property values and has decades of combined experience. The company offers a mix of acquisition and management services and performs comprehensive marketing research to develop customized investment strategies. Full reviews of properties are available, and property owners receive detailed operating budgets and periodic program status reporting. ...Read More

Key Real Estate Advisors, Inc.
239-454-3749 Click to Call Visit Site

Key Real Estate Advisors, Inc.

10231 Metro Parkway, #102 Fort Myers, FL 33966

Key Real Estate Advisors, Inc., provides residential property management services in South Florida from its offices in Fort Myers. The team offers a range of marketing solutions for property owners and assists in minimizing vacancy times. Screening includes comprehensive background and credit checks, and the real estate agents handle all the other aspects of the rental process, from signing the lease to handling notices and evictions. Property owners get extra peace of mind with a 90-day guarantee that allows them to cancel the contract and get a refund for management fees if they are not completely satisfied in the first three months. ...Read More

LandQwest Commercial Real Estate Services
239-275-4922 Click to Call Visit Site

LandQwest Commercial Real Estate Services

1614 Colonial Boulevard, #101 Fort Myers, FL 33907

LandQwest Commercial Real Estate Services is a Florida-based, full-service real estate company that has been serving commercial customers in the area since 2005. The team works from offices in Fort Myers, Tampa and Orlando to provide a number of real estate services, which include property management, retail services, industrial services, land services and consulting. President Mary Gentile has more than 22 years of experience in property management, and she is the Vice President for the Real Estate Investment Society (REIS) in Southwest Florida. ...Read More

Lyons Real Estate, Inc.
239-560-6164 Click to Call Visit Site

Lyons Real Estate, Inc.

4575 Via Royale, Unit 206 Fort Myers, FL 33907

Lyons Real Estate, Inc., is a residential real estate management firm that serves Fort Myers, Lehigh Acres, Cape Coral, San Carlos Park, Naples and Bonita Springs. It focuses on giving both property owners and tenants individual attention and handles all leasing matters. Online account management services are available, and the team handles all repairs and maintenance during the tenancy. Management services for property owners include a thorough tenant screening process, 24/7 access to owner statements, and support and guidance throughout the contract. ...Read More

Malt Realty & Development CO.
239-936-1320 Click to Call Visit Site

Malt Realty & Development CO.

1614 Colonial Boulevard, Suite 102 Fort Myers, FL 33907

A full-service real estate company that serves Southwest Florida, Malt Realty & Development CO. has over 40 decades of experience in property management and sales. The company doesn't charge an initial management fee for property owners and does meticulous background and credit checks to find suitable tenants. Other services offered by the team include 24/7 property maintenance services and marketing and advertising for various types of properties. President David G. Malt has purchased and developed over $100 million worth of property throughout his career and is a State of Florida Licensed Real Estate Broker and a member of Fort Myers Association of Realtors. ...Read More

Pro Management Realty
239-997-6468 Click to Call Visit Site

Pro Management Realty

15550 McGregor Boulevard, Suite 204 Fort Myers, FL 33908

Pro Management Realty provides a wide range of real estate services in multiple southeast Florida areas, including Cape Coral, Lehigh Acres, Miami and Naples. The property management team focuses on sourcing and vetting suitable tenants to avoid vacancy periods and keep things running smoothly. Property owners get peace of mind when they hire Pro Management Realty, as the team performs routine property checks and shares before and after pictures for all repairs. The company communicates with the tenants in a timely manner and handles all issues that may arise during a tenancy. ...Read More

Real Property Management Rental Direction
239-240-8111 Click to Call Visit Site

Real Property Management Rental Direction

12811 Kenwood Lane, Suite 102 Fort Myers, FL 33907

A full-service property management company with the main office in Fort Myers, Real Property Management Rental Direction serves multiple areas in South Florida, including Naples, Estero, Bonita Springs and Cape Coral, among others. The dedicated team offers complete property management services for landlords, handling all types of property, including condos, houses and multiplexes. Services include full-service leasing, regular inspections, cost-effective maintenance and accounting. For tenants, the company offers an online account that allows them to pay rent online and makes it easy to request repairs and maintenance. ...Read More

Realty Rents & Sales LLC
239-225-1234 Click to Call Visit Site

Realty Rents & Sales LLC

15880 Summerlin Road, Suite #300, Box #400 Fort Myers, FL 33908

Realty Rents & Sales LLC is a full-service property management company in southwest Florida that specializes in residential properties. The experienced team helps property owners find qualified tenants and achieve a high return on their investment. Besides tenant placement services, the company also offers buyer client services that include short sales and foreclosures and help for first-time homebuyers. Realty Rents & Sales LLC guarantees that all customers will always deal directly with the owner of the company. ...Read More

Red Fortress Property Management
239-939-1233 Click to Call Visit Site

Red Fortress Property Management

2525 Parkway Street Fort Myers, FL 33901

Red Fortress Property Management Company is the most experienced residential property management company in Southwest Florida and has been offering its services for nearly 40 years. Despite it being the only nationally certified as well as an award-winning company, the company prides itself on its personalized services and works with single-family homeowners, landlords and investors. Let our experience produce results for you! We are constantly improving our systems through professional education and technology to ensure that we continue to be a leader in the industry. ...Read More

Rentifi Property Management
239-292-0454 Click to Call Visit Site

Rentifi Property Management

12553 New Brittany Boulevard, #32 Ft. Myers, FL 33907

Rentifi Property Management is a premier provider of high quality, customized solutions in and around Fort Myers. For more than 30 years, the real estate management firm has been specializing in property leasing and management to provide owners with peace of mind. The team provides high-quality services that maximize returns on investments while taking the pressure off of the property owners. It also offers various types of protection, including customer service and 60-day money-back guarantee. Rentifi's mission is to provide a convenient and flexible property management process at a competitive rate. Founded by Investors, For Investors. ...Read More

Royal Palm Property Management Inc.
239-223-2116 Click to Call Visit Site

Royal Palm Property Management Inc.

813 Lake McGregor Drive Fort Myers, FL 33919

Royal Palm Property Management, Inc., specializes in management services in Fort Myers and the Southwest Florida area. The company provides a range of property management services for landlords, landowners and investors while also helping prospective tenants find a suitable home. This is a full service property management company founded by investors for investors. Royal Palms services include professional marketing, tenant screening, financial reporting, rent collection and more. ...Read More

Sandpiper Realty & Management LLC
239-289-6814 Click to Call Visit Site

Sandpiper Realty & Management LLC

15800-3, Brothers Court Fort Myers, FL 33912

Sandpiper Realty & Management LLC is a full-service property management company with a sound knowledge of the areas of Fort Myers, Estero, Bonita Springs and Naples. However, the agents can help prospective buyers or renters find a suitable property anywhere in Florida. The team of real estate agents offers assistance with purchases and sales, rentals and property management. Individual and corporate relocation assistance is available, and the company offers comprehensive property management services. These include running credit reports and criminal, background and eviction checks, as well as collecting and distributing rental income. ...Read More

Streamlined Property Management & Real Estate
239-491-2292 Click to Call Visit Site

Streamlined Property Management & Real Estate

411 Lee Boulevard, Suite 2 Lehigh Acres, FL 33936

Streamlined Property Management is a full-service property management company that serves the areas of Cape Coral, Fort Myers and Lehigh Acres. It covers a wide range of real estate services, including help for those looking to purchase a new home or rent a property or property owners who need a reliable company to manage their properties. The team helps owners find well-qualified tenants and get a high return for their investment. It performs rigorous background and financial checks and handles all aspects of the leasing process, from providing tenants with a secure online portal for paying rent to processing maintenance requests. ...Read More

The Property Place of SW FL, Inc.
239-995-1133 Click to Call Visit Site

The Property Place of SW FL, Inc.

3949 Evans Avenue Fort Myers, FL 33901

The Property Place of SW FL, Inc., has provided residential rental management services to owners since 1998. The team provides property owners with a wide range of marketing solutions that are all designed with minimizing vacancy times in mind. It is a full-service property company that covers everything from marketing the property and tenant screening to lease preparation, rent collection and handling maintenance and repairs. For tenants, The Property Place of SW FL, Inc., offers an online portal to pay rent and submit maintenance requests. ...Read More

Uptown Property Services
239-898-4540 Click to Call Visit Site

Uptown Property Services

2400 First Street, #212 Fort Myers, FL 3390

A family-owned and operated business, Uptown Property Services provides full real estate services to customers in Collier, Lee and Charlotte Counties. Owner Stacy Garcia has years of experience and used her knowledge to help buyers, sellers and investors to maximize their investment. Services are available for buyers, sellers, property owners looking for a capable agency to manage their properties and tenants. Rental property management services cover everything from tenant screenings and rent collection to a 24-hour on-call maintenance service. ...Read More

VIP Annual Rentals LLC
239-481-6111 Click to Call Visit Site

VIP Annual Rentals LLC

13131 University Drive Fort Myers, FL 33907

VIP Annual Rentals LLC focuses on offering complete real estate services for those who own rental properties or are looking to rent in Fort Myers, Bonita Springs, Cape Coral, Estero, Lehigh Acres and Naples. Sarah LaLande and Trula Rowley, the founders of the company, have over 25 years of experience each and comprehensive knowledge of the southwest Florida area. VIP Annual Rentals LLC employs the latest technologies to improve the rental experience for both tenants and owners. Multiple types of properties are handled, including condos and single-family homes. ...Read More