The Best Property Management in Amarillo, TX

The Best Property Management in Amarillo, TX

We considered all 46 Property Management Companies in the Amarillo area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 11.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Amarillo area.

  • shape-1 46
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 21
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 11
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 11 Best Property Management Companies in Amarillo

Show Map

Benji Hillside LLC

8201 West Boulevard Amarillo, TX 79124

Locally owned and operated, Benji Hillside LLC is a property management firm that rents luxury townhomes and duplexes. The company has over three decades of experience, and its properties are kept up-to-date and all maintenance needs are promptly handled. Tenants can view and apply for a lease online as well as pay rent and submit a service request. Rental properties are located at Hillside Terrace Estates and Townsquare Village. Both locations are near Westgate Mall, a variety of theaters and a large selection of dining options. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy with the service they receive from Benji Hillside. One customer wrote about an employee from the company that “went above and beyond for us” by helping him find a property and secure the rental on the agent’s day off. The customer went on to say the company is “honest and trustworthy.”

BLAZE Property Group

313 Bell, Suite 201 Amarillo, TX 79106

BLAZE Property Group is a full-service property management firm that also handles real estate sales. This allows them to offer homeowners looking to sell, buy, rent or lease homes a comprehensive approach to the market. Residential landlords can maximize their profits via BLAZE’s rental market analysis and the proprietary qualification process ensures that tenants are qualified and trustworthy. The property management company is well-networked in Amarillo, TX, which means potential tenants can generally be sourced in a minimal amount of time to prevent vacancies. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy with their owner and tenant services with one client stating that he would “recommend them for any property owner that needs anything from maintenance to full-service management.” A former tenant remarked they “get work done quickly” and are “honest and trustworthy.” One owner stated that he is very happy with their full suite of property management services and would "recommend them from maintenance to full-service management."

Collier-Mitchell Property Management

1613 3rd Avenue Canyon, TX 79105

Collier-Mitchell Property Management is dedicated to helping residential customers easily manage their properties and avoid costly mistakes. The company offers clients aid with tenant selection, a full suite of property management services and property rental assistance. The company’s prime goal is to take the stress out of renting, and to that end, it handles every aspect of home leases and real estate rentals from start to finish. The company handles family homes, fourplexes and duplexes and works with homeowners and investors. Available services include property maintenance, leasing, tenant qualifying, leasing, tenant evictions and routine inspections. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers remark that the office staff is “extremely cordial, helpful, and responsive.” Business clients speak highly of Collier-Mitchell Property Management and that their “building is immaculate” and that the company only hires “quality people” to handle maintenance tasks.

FIMC Commercial

1619 Tyler Amarillo, TX 79102

FIMC Commercial Realty is a full-service real estate firm that can offer property management services along with leasing, brokerage and consultation to customers. The company works with residential clients that need help leasing their home and large investment companies who need aid with site selection, property management and large investment management. Opened in 1986, the company utilizes AMSI’s state-of-the-art, web-based property management software to manage financials and offer full-service accounting support to clients. FIMC Commercial Realty is an Accredited Management Organization. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviews are generally positive with one customer remarking that the company was able to quickly help him find a home and they offered him “exactly what (he) was looking for.” Employees also speak highly of the company, stating that the management team is also happy to assist in solving any client problems.

Hartman Property Solutions LLC

5600 Bell Street, Suite 105 Amarillo, TX 79109

Over the last decade, Hartman Property Solutions LLC has grown to be a leader in property management and now handles apartment buildings, residential leases and commercial high rises. The company provides an array of property management services that include leasing, legal support and consulting. Owner, Kelby Hartman, has extensive experience in roofing/construction and home renovation which greatly enhances the range of property maintenance tasks associated with property management the company can handle in-house for customers. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Several customers remarked that they have never had any issues with their rental properties and that the office staff was “very pleasant to deal with.” Another past customer commented that the company went out of their way to meet with them after hours

Key Realty Amarillo

3600 Coulter, Suite A Amarillo, TX 79109

Key Realty is a comprehensive real estate firm that offers commercial and residential property management to customers. Founded in 2008, the company is primarily run by owner/broker David Velasquez who is assisted by several agents and realtors. While the company primarily focuses on buying/selling real estate, they do offer property management services to customers who need quick assistance filling a vacancy in their home or rental management from afar. Velasquez founded the company following his retirement as a Marine and is dedicated to ensuring customer satisfaction. The company also offers tenants a military discount ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers remark that David is “very knowledgeable” about the Amarillo market and is able to “back his strategy with real stats.” Several other customers mentioned what a “great guy” David is and that he was able to sell their home when other larger groups were not.

Latham Hometown Realty

4211 Tulia Drive Amarillo, TX 79109

Latham Hometown Realty is primarily a real estate office that also offers property management services to clients who want to rent or lease their homes. The company is run by a husband and wife team who have been working in real estate in Texas for the past three decades. All of Latham’s REALTORs are fully licensed, and owner Lyndon Latham is an Accredited Buyer Representative and active in both the Texas Association of REALTORS and the national branch. The company primarily works with residential clients. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

There are no written reviews available for this business.

Llano Estacado Management Company

1000 South Jefferson Street Amarillo, TX 79101

Llano Estacado Management Company is an asset management firm with a property management arm that professionally handles all of the time-consuming tasks of being a landlord. Llano Estacado handles tenant screening, rent collection, property maintenance, accounting, cleaning between tenants, enforcement of lease provisions, property showings and property advertising. Llano Estacado offers owners access to an online owner portal where they can access a financial performance evaluation of properties and electronically transfer funds. In addition to property management, Llano Estacado also offers note servicing, valuation analysis and brokerage services. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are generally positive about their experience as tenants with Llano Estacado with many remarking that they are “budget-friendly” and offer “prompt response” to problems and maintenance issues. Others comment that the staff is great and very easy to communicate with. One customer also remarked that they have great pet-friendly policies.

McCartt Commercial Real Estate Services

800 S. Polk, Suite 104 Amarillo, TX 79101

McCartt Commercial Real Estate Services is a comprehensive real estate firm that offers property management, buyer representation, tenant representation, and brokerage and development consultation. The company currently manages over 1,500,000 square feet of commercial properties but also manages empty lots, medical spaces and multifamily properties. The company is comprised of property managers, licensed agents, accountants and facilities managers to ensure properties remain profitable and on track. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

While reviews are limited, one customer did state that the company is comprised of “fabulous people” who are willing to work hard to ensure the customers’ satisfaction.

Minnix Property Management

12303 Slide Road Lubbock, TX 79424

Minnix Property Management provides property management solutions to customers with the intent of building lasting relationships via strong service and quality housing options. The company provides owners with an array of management services including rental marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance issues, evictions and dealing with tenant complaints. Minnix Property Management works with residential customers and owners of multifamily rentals who need assistance in managing their investment assets. The company offers residents the option to pay rent online and request repairs via a tenant portal. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers rave about the positive experiences they have with office staff at Minnix, with one customer remarking that “they are always willing to help” and another calling the receptionist “a beautiful person to speak with.” Others appreciate how quickly they were able to rent a home and the fact that “maintenance is quick to respond and fix any issues.”

Pat Davis Properties

4001 South Western Street Amarillo, TX 79109

For the past 25 years, Pat Davis Properties has offered property management as well as brokerage, leasing and investment services to the greater Amarillo area. The full-service commercial real estate firm specializes in residential and commercial property management and investment property management. Owners have access to a full suite of management services including billing, contract administration, tenant relations, maintenance programs, management reports and general ledger accounting. A recipient of the Amarillo Chamber of Commerce's Top Small Business Award, Pat Davis Properties is also a member of the National Association of REALTORS. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Many commercial customers remark that their experience is exceptional and that Pat Davis is always ready to “meet their needs.” Tenants also remark that they respond promptly and are great at keeping properties up to date. Others remarked that the company displays a strong “willingness to put the tenant first.”

Property Management in Nearby Cities