The Best Property Management Companies in Fayetteville, NC

The Best Property Management Companies in Fayetteville, NC

We considered all 128 Property Management Companies in the Fayetteville area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 21.

The Best Property Management Companies in Fayetteville, NC

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Fayetteville area.

  • shape-1 128
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 57
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 21
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    An extensive track record of reliable, honest service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Understands property laws and industry best practices.

  • 3. Experience

    Knowledge of your property to save you time and money.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Provides transparent, fair pricing and great communication.

The 21 Best Property Management Companies in Fayetteville

Show Map

AAIMS Property Management

100 Westlake Road Fayetteville, NC 28314

AAIMS Property Management has been serving residential property owners and tenants in Cumberland, Hoke and Harnett counties since 1984. It manages a large selection of single-family homes, townhomes, condominiums and apartments within Fayetteville and the surrounding areas. The company streamlines processes and facilitates efficient communication with investors and tenants through dedicated online portals that feature a simplified, secure payment system, owners' financial statements, residents' maintenance requests and a built-in messaging system for faster collaboration. Property owners are assured that their investments are well taken care of through well-documented move-in and ongoing inspections. The group also provides basic and full-service management services to homeowners associations. AAIMS Property Management holds an Accredited Management Organization certification from the Institute of Real Estate Managemen ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers appreciate the team's sense of initiative, responsiveness and prompt communication. The efficient application process and fast turnaround time for filling up vacancies also received positive feedback. A long-time client says, "I've had an excellent experience working with Kristy at AAIMS! She's been managing our property for many years, and I can't say how much extra time and energy she's put into our house which is important considering we've moved around the world during the 20 years it's been with AAIMS!"

Ace Real Estate

207 Fairway Drive Fayetteville, NC 28305

Ace Real Estate helps North Carolina investors buy, sell and manage their investment residential properties. Tenants can easily find properties managed by this company through the variety of online real estate markets it canvases and see properties with attractive professional photos in its listings. New tenants are discovered and carefully screened and lease document preparation is prepared in-office. The courteous staff efficiently handles all tenant communications including financial issues and maintenance requests, among other issues. The team of licensed brokers handles all aspects of the leasing process and offer investors local knowledge, having served the area since 2006. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Property owners and tenants that leave reviews online say they genuinely appreciate this group's dedication to a fast response and timely care of any needs. As one owner recently writes on Yelp, "Throughout 10 years, ACE has kept our condo consistently leased with tenants. They've informed us of necessary repairs and used their list of home professionals to resolve the problems... He prepared our condo for a showing... The marketing and photos were eye-catching."

Brown Property Group

2557 Ravenhill Drive, Suite 1B Fayetteville, NC 28303

Brown Property Group is a locally owned and operated company that provides property management services in Cumberland and neighboring counties through its central office in Fayetteville, North Carolina. It handles all types of properties, including single-family, multifamily and commercial properties. A team of skilled property managers focuses on maximizing investment returns, providing a management program that consists of maintenance, inspections, marketing, tenant screening, lease agreement preparation, rent collections and eviction proceedings. Services are delivered promptly and efficiently through the use of the AppFolio Property Manager software, and owners have access to an online portal for on-demand statements and maintenance invoices. Brown Property Group is a member of the National Association of REALTORS and the National Association of Residential Property Managers ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The company's clients are mostly satisfied with its services, noting that the team is detail-oriented, knowledgeable, prompt and professional. Investors also liked the regular inspections they do on properties and how they're well represented by the group. "Brown Property Group takes full ownership in the properties they manage. After working with several in the area, I can confidently say Bobby Brown was most helpful. This is a great partnership to start whether you are a new or experienced investor," says an impressed client.

Complete Concept Realty

201 S McPherson Church Road # 200 Fayetteville, NC 28303

Complete Concept Realty handles the management of residential and commercial properties for Fayetteville and Raeford-area owners with a specialty in buying and selling properties. This innovative group offers owners the option to market their houses simultaneously on the market as well as to renters to ensure the quickest income generation. New tenants can search the leasing website to find new homes and reach out to the friendly agents here to apply for tenancy. All background screenings and lease preparation are completed by Complete Concept Realty, as is all ongoing communication with tenants. Applications, maintenance requests and rent payments can be submitted online. This group also handles any issues with housing associations for multifamily residence owners. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

"Carlene is an amazing Realtor! She walked us through the whole process and answered all our questions. She's very knowledgeable and passionate about her job," writes one satisfied client online recently. Other reviewers give nod to this company's dedication to customer service as well as making sure problems with properties are resolved in a speedy manner.

CornerStone Real Estate

120 Westlake Road, Suite 4 Fayetteville, NC 28314

CornerStone Real Estate provides property management services to clients in Fayetteville and Fort Bragg, North Carolina, and the nearby counties of Cumberland, Hoke and Harnet. It specializes in residential investment properties, including single-family homes, duplexes, condominiums and townhomes, providing full management services that maximize investors' income and ensure well-maintained homes for tenants. The company keeps track of the area's vacancy rates, vacancy factors and rent values for effective marketing and maintains a network of qualified contractors to promptly address maintenance issues. Its comprehensive management program also includes tenant screening, lease agreement preparation, rent collection, tenant relations and detailed accounting of the properties' performance. CornerStone Real Estate uses HERO PM to effectively manage its processes and collaborate with clients through advanced cloud-based solutions. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers praised the company for its reasonable fees and easy process. They liked that the team has good communication skills, quickly finds tenants, easy to get in touch with and keeps issues under control. Many long-time clients expressed satisfaction, with one saying, "After 6 years, I can say with confidence that Cornerstone is the most pleasant and professional Property management company in Fayetteville. From top to bottom, it feels like family. They truly know how to treat people!"

Donovan Properties

3820 Raeford Road Fayetteville, NC 28304

Founded in 2008, Donovan Properties provides property management services in Fayetteville and the surrounding areas in North Carolina. Its team of professionals strives to make investments profitable through comprehensive management services that include marketing and advertising of vacancies, prospective tenant screening, timely property maintenance, property survey, rent and deposit collection and tenant relations. The company uses leading-edge software, with owners and tenants having access to dedicated online portals. Fully computerized monthly statements are sent to property owners, showing detailed accounts of all income and disbursements, while rent and deposit collections are subjected to periodic auditing for accuracy and transparency. Working closely with property owners, the group ensures tenants of well-maintained properties, with maintenance service requests conveniently submitted through the online portal. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Clients are pleased that the company's representatives attended to issues promptly and are willing to answer all questions. They praised the group's excellent customer service and the helpful, friendly team. A number of reviewers described their positive experiences, with one saying, "Great ladies to work with and excellent customer service. I had no complaints. If it wasn't for me moving out of state, I would've definitely used them again. It's hard to find good property managers that actually care."

Grant-Murray Real Estate LLC

150 N. McPherson Church Road, Suite A Fayetteville, NC 28303

Grant-Murray Real Estate LLC was founded in 2011 and offers leasing, property management, tenant representation and site selection services to clients in Fayetteville and the surrounding areas. Its property management division caters to commercial, multifamily and residential property owners. The team provides a broad range of services that include revenue management, property maintenance and engineering, lease administration and support, procurement of vendor service contracts, financial management and tenant relations. Providing high-tech sophistication to its processes, the company has dedicated online portals in place for secure owner and tenant transactions. Grant-Murray Real Estate also provides lease and landlord representation services for buildings, shopping centers and industrial facilities. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers noted how the team at Grant-Murray Real Estate represents clients in the best possible manner and were impressed with their extensive knowledge of the Fayetteville market. "I had owned a small shopping center that was under-performing and had several vacancies. Through a friend, I was referred to Macon Thomason, a leasing and sales agent with Grant-Murray Real Estate. After enlisting Mr. Thomason's services, he wound up leasing most of the center," says a satisfied property owner.

Guardian Property Management

2915 Raeford Road, Suite 101 Fayetteville, NC 28303

Serving the Fayetteville and Fort Bragg area, Guardian Property Management offers a full menu of real estate services to owners of residential properties. Advertising properties across a wide range of platforms and through its state-of-the-art online management system, this group finds local tenants fast to maximize turnaround on vacancies. Guardian helps owners keep properties in pristine shape and ensures no property emergency goes unchecked with round-the-clock repair services. Its team of experienced local vendors provides ongoing groundskeeping as well as any regular maintenance needs. Thorough initial inspections are carefully compared to move-out inspections to ensure owners are compensated for any damages that occurred during their tenants' stay. Detailed financial reports are provided to owners, and rents are deposited to their accounts automatically each month. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants appreciate the dedication to service provided by this team. One tenant says, "Rented a property in the Haymount area for about a year from Guardian. As to be expected with these older historic homes, there were issues from time to time. Rhonda and her team went above and beyond to resolve any problem little or small!"

Homeowners Property Management

5509 Yadkin Road Fayetteville, NC 28303

Homeowners Property Management, Inc., is a full-service home rental agency serving Fayetteville and surrounding areas within a 25-mile radius from its office location. Established in 1976 as the rental department of a real estate sales firm, this company grew to become its own independent agency and successfully manages over 1,000 residential properties. On behalf of property owner clients, Homeowners Property Management takes care of the maintenance, online marketing, tenant screening, rent collection and eviction processes. This company uses online management software that supports online applications, rent payments, electronic signatures and automated updates on property reports and accounts. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Clients are impressed by how Homeowners Property Management handles rental properties with efficiency and great attention to detail, while tenants commend the company for its excellent customer service. One real estate owner writes, "They've been prompt with every communication, have actually saved us money in the long run by getting tenants in promptly and at a good rental rate, and have spared us a lot of hassles by handling repairs. They are quick with advice and particular about keeping things looking good. They work as a team and are always accessible when I contact them."

Little & Young

2939 Breezewood Avenue #100 Fayetteville, NC 28303

Founded in 1996, Little & Young is a locally owned company that operates in Fayetteville, North Carolina, providing property management services for residential homes, condominiums, apartments and commercial properties. It markets and advertises rental properties through personal showings, media ads, referrals and multiple listing services. With a comprehensive maintenance program and emergency repair system in place, the company ensures that properties maintain their high standards to maximize the rental income of investors. Its full-service rental management program also includes tenant screening, lease execution and rent collection. Computerized accounting and data processing facilitates efficient operation and accurate reporting, and owners have access to annual condition and inventory reports, direct bank deposits, expense and income records, monthly statements and year-end tax summaries. Additionally, Little & Young provides management services to Homeowners Associations. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

The company got high ratings for its great management team, prompt action to problems and issues, quick response time to emails and queries, friendly staff and timely repairs. One property owner recommends the company, saying, "Little & Young managed our rental for three years and they have been absolutely nothing but wonderful to work with the whole time. Cheyenne, in particular, is extremely professional and very prompt in her follow-through. Highly recommend them!"

Nest Managers Real Estate

1318 Fort Bragg Road Fayetteville, NC 28305

Nest Managers Real Estate provides Fayetteville area property owners with superior customer service, specializing in managing single-family homes and small multi-family properties. Owners can customize their management service packages, using its services simply to market their properties to the widest audience or utilizing its full-service package. Flexible contract options allow for short- and long-term property management. This company handles all aspects of leasing, from advertising and finding new tenants to vetting them with diligent background screening. Quarterly, yearly and ongoing maintenance inspections are completed with trusted professionals to ensure properties are kept in top condition. Properties are photographed with professional real estate photographers for top notch marketing. With professional marketing services, homes lease 5x faster than the area standard. Owners enjoy the company's commitment to transparency of being notified immediately of any maintenance requests, comprehensive inspection reports and 24/7 financial record access. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

"Nest has been managing my property for over a year now. They have done an excellent job. Anytime I had any concerns or issues they would notify me and offer quick and inexpensive options to remedy the situation. Their advertising services are the best. In less than 3 days they managed to lease my property with highly qualified tenants. I strongly recommend their services," writes one highly satisfied investor online.

Oakmont Property Management

2825 Breezewood Avenue Fayetteville, NC 28303

Oakmont Property Management was founded in 2017 and manages rental properties in Fayetteville, Hope Mills, Raeford and Spring Lake, North Carolina. Specializing in single-family homes and multifamily communities, the company strives to create long-term personalized relationships with both owners and tenants. It maximizes investors' rental income through its comprehensive management services that include property evaluation and comparative market analysis, multiplatform advertising, applicant screening and thorough background checks, lease execution and rent collection. Semiannual property inspections are conducted and documented through written reports and pictures. The team handles all necessary communication with tenants, including lease renewals, maintenance concerns and eviction proceedings. Owners are provided with monthly financial records and annual tax statements which can be accessed through a dedicated portal. An online tenant portal is also in place for secure payments and maintenance requests. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers appreciate that owners are kept informed and tenants are well taken care of. A client praised the company's management and finds the group highly recommendable, saying, "We have worked with Janell for years. She is undoubtedly the best property manager in the Cumberland and Harnett county area. There are so many management companies in the area with horrible reputations. Do yourself a favor and give Oakmont Property Management a call."

Pathfinder Realty Partners

585 S Reilly Road Fayetteville, NC 28314

Pathfinder Realty Partners offers real estate investors in the greater Fayetteville area a full range of residential property management services. Owners use this company for all of their property needs, from finding and managing tenants to maintaining the property. Using a wide range of marketing tools, this group blankets the local market with professional listings of properties designed to attract the most well-qualified applicants. The friendly in-office leasing team handles all communications with prospective and current tenants, including inspection processes and lease preparation. Owners utilize its state-of-the-art online portal to access account statements and rent receipts at any time as well as the status of their properties maintenance work orders. Rents are automatically collected from tenants and posted to owners' accounts monthly with detailed statements. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

"The team at Pathfinder has done a fantastic job managing our home and keeping it continually leased over the past four years. As an out of state homeowner, we're grateful to have a management company we can trust and rely on," writes a satisfied property owner in an online testimonial.

Peachtree Properties of Fayetteville

3310 South Peak Drive Fayetteville, NC 28306

Founded in 1996, Peachtree Properties of Fayetteville is a locally owned full-service real estate company that provides property management services to clients in Fayetteville, Raeford and the surrounding areas. To actively market and advertise rentals, the company lists properties in the Fayetteville Observer, the Fayetteville multiple listing service, Fort Bragg and Pope AFB housing offices and the company's website. Prospective tenants are thoroughly screened based on credit checks from Equifax, referrals from previous landlords and verification of employment and income. To ensure that rental homes maintain their excellent condition, the company's property management services also include maintenance and repair coordination, as well as comprehensive move-in, move-out and routine inspections which are properly documented through digital photos. Peachtree Properties of Fayetteville also offers new and existing homes for sale in the counties of Cumberland, Hoke and Harnett. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Reviewers praised the kind and professional staff, the accommodating office manager and the responsive repair department. They appreciate the open communication, quick response to issues and the smooth process. "Peachtree has been managing my property for over 3 years, and I have been nothing but satisfied. They managed my property like it was their own personal property. My property has been carefully taken care of, and always maintained," commented one homeowner.

Peery's Property Management, LLC

5135 Morganton Road, Suite 104 Fayetteville, NC 28314

Since 2002, Peery's Property Management has been serving property owners, investors and tenants in the Fayetteville/Ft. Bragg, NC, region. The company specializes in single-family and small residences such as condominiums, duplexes and townhomes. It offers full management services from marketing and leasing to full accounting of properties. It creates and cultivates working relationships with clients as well as service vendors to ensure high-quality, timely responses to property needs. The firm combines extensive experience handling virtually all types of property and tenancy situations with a state-of-the-art cloud-based portal to provide thorough, knowledgeable communication and efficient, personalized service. Peery's Property Management is a member of HERO PM and the National Association of Residential Property Managers. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Peery's Property Management has earned a reputation for dependability, efficiency, caring attitude and quick responses. One satisfied client remarked, "I have rented four different properties from Peery's over the past 10 years and have ALWAYS had a top notch experience! Their professionalism, attention to detail and prompt response to any and all situations is what made me a long term tenant! ... I wouldn't hesitate to rent, buy or sell any property through them!"

Rental Management Company

5506 Yadkin Road Fayetteville, NC 28303

Rental Management Company (RMC) offers property management services to residential real estate investors in Fayetteville. RMC provides owners with a complete service package at competitive, transparent rates. Rental properties are assessed for repair needs and photographed with professional cameras to add to their online and newspaper listings. Newly discovered tenants are carefully screened with thorough background and credit checks. Initial and ongoing inspections are completed with this team of friendly leasing agents, and residents can easily submit maintenance requests online, ensuring properties are always kept in the best shape possible. Financial statements are prepared monthly for owners as well as annually for tax preparation and year-end accounting. Rents are collected daily and payments are sent to owners within three days of payment clearing. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants appreciate the efficiency offered here, as one happy resident writes, "I am very pleased with this company. I've been renting from them for a few months now, and they always take care of any problem that we have." Owners also love this group, writing, "I have been a property owner with this company for 17 years, and I have NEVER had an issue with them!"

Sada's Properties

4008 Colorado Drive Hope Mills, NC 28348

Sada's Properties provides full-service property management services to real estate investors in the Fayetteville area. The company's immersive marketing strategies help owners keep their properties at the top of the list when local tenants search for properties. Tenants communicate directly with Sada's Properties' professional leasing agents to complete all background screening and move-in inspections. Rent can be paid and maintenance requests put in easily online. Owners can access the status of their properties and finances through this team's secure online portal. Properties are well-maintained with regular walk-through inspections and cleaning services to ensure the ongoing health of properties. Monthly and annual performance reports are prepared to keep investors on top of their real estate income. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Investors appreciate this team's focus on taking care of everything an owner needs to keep their properties filled. "She has been doing a great job getting the house ready for tenants. Absolutely, will continue using here," writes one satisfied property owner in a Facebook review. Other reviews online notice this company's dedication to customer service, writing simply that this company is staffed by "Wonderful people!"

Strother Property Management

225 Ray Avenue Fayetteville, NC 28301

Strother Property Management is a Fayetteville-based company offering leasing and management services for property owners in Fayetteville, Fort Bragg and the counties of Cumberland, Harnett, Hoke, Lee and Moore in North Carolina. Its portfolio includes residential homes, townhouses and condominiums, catering to different lifestyles and budgets. Using the AppFolio software, the company delivers efficient services to its clients through web-based technology. Properties are professionally advertised through the company's website, Craiglist and other web-based platforms, and filling up of vacancy postings are expedited through online tenant applications. Owners are able to monitor their property's performance through monthly statements sent through email or accessed through the online owner portal. Tenants are provided with a dedicated online portal that accepts secure online payments and maintenance requests. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Several highly rated reviews for Strother Property Management mention how the team puts in hard work and dedication, is helpful with issues, detail-oriented and organized. Clients also praised the company's professionalism. "Cindy and Brandy helped me organize my rental property, clean it up, and get a renter within two weeks. Outstanding service. I'm excited to work with them in the future," commented one impressed homeowner.

The Best Group Real Estate Services

6562 Brookshire Street Fayetteville, NC 28314

The Best Group Real Estate Services is a family operated company that provides professional property management services for clients in Fayetteville, Raeford, Spring Lake and the surrounding areas in North Carolina. As a small company, it provides customized services that fit the clients' individual needs, including rent collection, tenant management based on lease agreements, repair and maintenance coordination, property inspections and eviction processing. Vacancies are advertised on multiple web-based platforms such as Zillow, Hotpads and Trulia, as well as by putting up physical signs on properties. Prospective tenants are screened for credit and past rental history, income, employment and criminal background. The Best Group Real Estate Services has the resources to foster landlord and tenant relationships and the capability to mitigate disputes when needed. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Satisfied clients find the company highly recommendable for owners and tenants alike, with positive feedback given to the excellent customer service, timely rent collection, prompt and quality maintenance repairs and the tenant application process. One property owner says, "The Best Group has managed my property for a little over two years. Ms. Williams has been nothing but professional and honest with me. Although she manages my property, she has never overstepped or made any decisions without consulting me first."

The Property Emporium

808 Hope Mills Road Fayetteville, NC 28304

The Property Emporium offers Fayetteville-area residential property owners superior residential management from a full menu of services. This group advertises rental properties across a wide range of networks and carefully screens all prospective tenants for background and rental history. New tenants can easily find as well as apply for properties through this group's smartphone app. Rents are easily paid online through the secure tenant portal. Payments are deposited into investors' accounts within two business days of payment clearing. The financial experts here provide owners with regular financial statements as well as bookkeeping assistance during tax season. Owners can access their accounts online 24/7 to view the status of their properties, including financial and maintenance documents and the status of ongoing issues. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Owners of properties managed by this group are pleased with its dedication to maintaining properties and recovering assets when damage exists after move-outs. As one property owner writes online, "The Property Emporium agents execute the rental contracts flawlessly. When tenants move out they have been great helping reset the property and getting a new tenant as quickly as possible. They have protected my investment properties for the past few years and have done great work."

The Williams Group

214 Hay Street Fayetteville, NC 28301

The Williams group provides investors in Fayetteville and the surrounding areas with a full range of property management services. The company works with a team of trusted local contractors to prepare homes for leasing as well as provide ongoing maintenance and emergency services. Prospective tenants easily find properties through this group's widespread advertising campaigns to get new rentals leased ou fast. The well-trained real estate agents here are happy to help owners of single- and multi-family homes with their local knowledge and expertise in the fields of bookkeeping and landlord/tenant law. Owners and tenants easily access their accounts to pay bills and view work orders 24/7 through the company's secure online portal. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Property owners value the peace of mind they get when choosing The Williams Group to manage their rental homes. As one Facebook review reads "[The] Williams Group stepped in and took over my rental property professionally and quickly evaluated any concerns of my property so that we may address them. [I'm] happy I chose them to take over my rental property." Owners and tenants alike agree that this group provides excellent customer service and satisfaction.

Property Management in Nearby Cities