The Best Property Management Companies in Milwaukee, Wisconsin of 2022

The Best Property Management Companies in Milwaukee, Wisconsin of 2022

We considered all 249 Property Management Companies in the Milwaukee area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 21.

The Best Property Management Companies in Milwaukee, Wisconsin of 2022

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Milwaukee area.

  • shape-1 249
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 112
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 21
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    An extensive track record of reliable, honest service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Understands property laws and industry best practices.

  • 3. Experience

    Knowledge of your property to save you time and money.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Provides transparent, fair pricing and great communication.

The 21 Best Property Management Companies in Milwaukee

Show Map
ABC Management, Inc.
414-225-3100 Click to Call Visit Site

ABC Management, Inc.

621 E. Pleasant Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202

ABC Management, Inc., founded in 1999, manages residential, commercial, and industrial properties. Their current portfolio includes over 700 units of multifamily real estate. ABC supports multifamily homes, office buildings, retail centers, industrial facilities, foreclosure properties, and condominium associations. Services include recruitment, agreements, maintenance, supervision, emergency service, and eviction action and coordination. Their team consists of legal counsel, licensed architects, engineers, HVAC technicians, plumbers, and electricians. ABC can be contacted by online form, phone, fax, or email. ...Read More

Bartsch Management, LLC
414-763-7160 Click to Call Visit Site

Bartsch Management, LLC

225 E Mason Street, #500, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Bartsch Management specializes in managing and selling single-family, duplex, and multifamily properties throughout Metro Milwaukee. They are an equal housing opportunity company, and their property management services include leasing, rent collection, online owner access to real-time reporting, bill disbursement, property inspection, and maintenance. Residents can pay rent, check their account balance, and submit service requests online by creating a login. Interested applicants can apply online and provide identification proof to be considered. ...Read More

Bell Property Management, Inc.
414-332-1117 Click to Call Visit Site

Bell Property Management, Inc.

2545 North Maryland Avenue, #102, Milwaukee, WI 53203

Bell Property Management, Inc., has buildings in multiple locations including the Eastside and Downtown Milwaukee. With other more suburban locations in New Berlin, Waukesha, and Hales Corners, there is something for everyone. The on-site property managers help maintain the buildings while giving residents direct contact with the company. Maintenance often handles requests within 24 hours, and emergency maintenance is available 24/7. Interested parties can register for a free account to save and submit an application online. ...Read More

Bieck Management, Inc.
414-961‑7400 Click to Call Visit Site

Bieck Management, Inc.

4080 N. Port Washington Road, Milwaukee, WI 53212

Bieck Management, Inc., has been a family-owned and operated firm serving Wisconsin since 1977. Their properties include residential, office, retail, commercial, and light industrial. A couple of their properties that stand out from competitors are condominiums and mobile homes. They have a plethora of rental properties available in multiple cities. Each listing has standard details, a contact from Bieck, a photo of the building, and an interactive map available. If interested, a pre-qualification application can be submitted online. ...Read More

Citywide Rentals
414-269-6446 Click to Call Visit Site

Citywide Rentals

8432 W Lisbon Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53222

Citywide Rentals and Property Management can help landlords with competitive rental rate setting, effective vacancy advertising, property showings, applicant screenings, lease signing and follow-through, property inspections, fee and rent collections, property maintenance, and evictions. The online portal allows owners to keep tabs on their property's financial state, and the tenant portal allows them to make rent payments and submit requests. Citywide Rentals can be contacted through the online form, or by phone or email. ...Read More

DAK Properties
414-351-1232 Click to Call Visit Site

DAK Properties

7448 N Teutonia Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53209

DAK Properties prides itself on owning and operating all of its properties and having in-house management. They service Milwaukee and areas such as Riverwest, Grafton, Thiensville, Germantown, Jackson, and Menomonee Falls. Being in business for over 25 years means they understand customer service and respect the fact that renters are home in their properties. Interested tenants can apply right from their vacant listings or schedule a viewing. Current tenants can pay rent, view their accounts, or submit maintenance requests through the portal. ...Read More

Jomela Properties
414-442-1700 Click to Call Visit Site

Jomela Properties

5601 W North Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53208

Jomela is a locally owned business with affordable rental housing for apartments, duplexes, and single-family homes. Their website hosts an owner portal and a tenant portal, along with a link to pay rent online and submit a maintenance request. For tenants to proceed with an online application, they will need to provide a government-issued photo ID, proof of income, and an application fee of $25.00. If a current Jomela resident refers someone who signs a lease, the client receives a credit. ...Read More

MPI Property Management LLC
414-933-2700 Click to Call Visit Site

MPI Property Management LLC

6700 W. Fairview Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53213

MPI Property Management LLC has been serving Milwaukee and Waukesha since 1978. In addition to property management, MPI assists landlords with eviction services when required. As a State of Wisconsin licensed home improvement contractor, maintenance staff can assist with everything from minor maintenance to major home renovations. For prospective tenants to fill out an application, they can download one online or bring their State ID, proof of income, and the contact information of their current and previous landlord(s). ...Read More

Northland Management, LLC
414-962-9775 Click to Call Visit Site

Northland Management, LLC

2720 N Frederick Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211

Northland Management has provided property management services to Milwaukee-area property owners for more than 50 years. Customers can submit repair requests and pay rent from any location, courtesy of the online tenant portal. The company offers on-site maintenance solutions. The staff creates an all-inclusive rental fee that includes utility bills such as heat, gas, water, and sewer. Customers can access services from 8:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. ...Read More

Ogden & Company, Inc.
414-276-5285 Click to Call Visit Site

Ogden & Company, Inc.

1665 N. Water Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Ogden & Company, Inc., has been operable in Milwaukee since 1929. They are the biggest full-service company in Wisconsin with about 200 employees in property management, brokerage, development, consulting, construction, and maintenance services. Their website helps residents find apartments, residential listings, or commercial listings, and owners will certainly find their community portal helpful. The Better Business Bureau has rated Ogden an A+ as of July 2019, and the Milwaukee Business Journal rated them in 2020 as one of the best places to work. ...Read More

Optimum Property Management
414-342-2120 Click to Call Visit Site

Optimum Property Management

2120 W. Clybourn Street, Milwaukee, WI 53233

Optimum Property Management has been in business since the 1970s, managing properties on a fee basis. Residents can easily contact management, make a rent payment, or submit a maintenance request through the website. Interested tenants can request more information on a specific apartment before they submit an application. Optimum is certified by the Milwaukee chapter of the Institute of Real Estate Management as an Accredited Management Organization and is a member of the National Apartment Association. ...Read More

Performance Asset Management
414-943-1038 Click to Call Visit Site

Performance Asset Management

2658 S Kinnickinnic Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Performance Asset Management is designed by investors for investors. They specialize in leasing, management, maintenance and renovations with no renewal fees, vacancy fees, or trip charges. The company is a member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM) and won a Visitor's Choice Award in 2016. Expertise.com has rated them one of the best property management companies in Waukesha for 2022. Performance Property Management boasts an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. ...Read More

Porch Light Property Management & Real Estate
414-678-1088 Click to Call Visit Site

Porch Light Property Management & Real Estate

6650 W State Street, Suite D221, Milwaukee, WI 53213

Porch Light Property Management & Real Estate is an equal opportunity housing provider managing apartments, town homes, and duplexes. Their website allows access to Flex Deposit, as well as an online rental application or cosigner application. Listings are automatically sorted by most recent, but properties can be searched for by location, rent, or bedrooms and bathrooms. A valid state ID, driver's license, passport, or military ID with a photo is mandatory for each applicant for proof of identity. ...Read More

Prospect Management LLC
414-540-0004 Click to Call Visit Site

Prospect Management LLC

224 N. 76th Street, Milwaukee, WI 53213

Prospect Management LLC serves Milwaukee, Madison, and Kenosha with condominium and homeowner association management. In business since 1999, they are one of the few companies in Wisconsin to specialize in these areas. For prospective clients to contact them, their website lists their email, telephone, and fax. They proudly hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and are a member of both the Accredited Association Management Company (AAMC) and Community Associations Institute. ...Read More

Rent Me WI
414-255-3806 Click to Call Visit Site

Rent Me WI

4735 W National Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53045

Rent Me WI assists investors with their real estate portfolios. Their services include rental property, acquisition, rehab/turnover, marketing, tenant screening, 24/7 maintenance, home inspections, and evictions and collections. Not only does Rent Me WI offer both a tenant portal and owner portal, their website allows prospective clients to get a free quote before committing to anything. They serve areas in Wisconsin such as Milwaukee, Madison, Appleton, and more. For social media savvy people, Rent Me's Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube are linked. ...Read More

Schulhof Property Management LLC
414-933-1211 Click to Call Visit Site

Schulhof Property Management LLC

825 North 16th Street, Milwaukee, WI 53233

Schulhof Property Management has been managing over 25 rental apartments for more than 30 years for the Marquette University Campus. They currently hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Apartments available for students are studios, one bedroom, two bedrooms, and three or more bedrooms. Schulhof also maintains three off-campus apartment buildings. Applications can be downloaded from their website along with rules and regulations and non-standard rental provisions. For any interested renters, they have a FAQ page to help with any questions. ...Read More

Structure Properties
414-882-8777 Click to Call Visit Site

Structure Properties

225 East St. Paul Avenue, Suite 302, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Structure Properties is a self-proclaimed boutique firm stationed in Milwaukee's Historic Third Ward. They focus on apartment complexes, town homes, single-family homes, and commercial investment properties. Structure Properties offers services such as property management, real estate buying and selling, real estate investment consulting, and co-working. In their online resident portal, tenants can submit maintenance requests, pay rent, and view their lease information or property announcements. Owners online can view bills, submit maintenance requests, view lease documents, and run reports. ...Read More

Trike Property Management
414-332-5500 Click to Call Visit Site

Trike Property Management

1534 N Humboldt Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Trike Property Management is a real estate investments and management service handling multifamily apartment buildings, offices (including medical offices), industrial, and retail. Their website allows prospective tenants to search for apartments as well as apply online. Once living there, tenants can also pay rent online and request maintenance as well. An applicant must be able to provide proof of combined gross income of at least three times the rent to qualify, among other guidelines. ...Read More

Welcome Home Milwaukee, LLC
414-797-1819 Click to Call Visit Site

Welcome Home Milwaukee, LLC

7311 W Greenfield Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53214

Welcome Home Milwaukee assists investors by handling acquisitions, renovations, leasing, managing, and maintaining properties. Their best package is $136 combining the monthly fee, placement fee, move out fee, renewal fee, and maintenance. For easy contact, they have a live chat box on their website, where you can leave a message even if it's outside business hours. Owners and residents have logins to monitor their accounts. Expertise.com rated them one of the best property management companies in Milwaukee in 2022.  ...Read More

Wilkins Property Management
414-224-7570 Click to Call Visit Site

Wilkins Property Management

1020 E Pleasant Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Wilkins Property Management has more than 10 years of experience helping Milwaukee citizens find the right apartment home. Tenants must have an average gross monthly income of three times the rent amount, have a good credit score, and have not had an eviction from the last 5 years on their record. A $25 charge covers the background and credit checks, and tenants must also provide photo ID and proof of income.  ...Read More

Zolper Property Management
414-962-8030 Click to Call Visit Site

Zolper Property Management

3477 North Oakland Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53211

Zolper Property Management's motto is "Making Milwaukee home since 1996". Their website homepage shows a helpful map of available apartment listings in the Greater Milwaukee area. Prospective tenants can find an open house or submit an application online. Listings can easily be searched by neighborhoods, statuses, and the number of beds and/or baths. Current tenants can request access to the online portal, where they can submit maintenance requests among other things. Zolper can be contacted through their online form, or by phone or email. ...Read More

Property Management in Nearby Cities