The Best Property Management in Lexington, KY

The Best Property Management in Lexington, KY

We considered all 99 Property Management Companies in the Lexington area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 22.

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Lexington area.

  • shape-1 99
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 45
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 22
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    A history of great customer reviews and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

The 22 Best Property Management Companies in Lexington

Show Map

Alltrade Property Management, LLC

1801 Alexandria Dr Suite 180 Lexington, KY 40504

Alltrade Property Management has been in business since 2005, providing a full range of property management services. Services offered include maintaining the property to make sure everything is in good repair and to keep it visually appealing. The company's service is customized to the unique needs of each client, and owners have online access to property records and financial statements. For renters, services include the ability to apply and pay online. A form is provided online for tenants who need to request maintenance on a property. Alltrade also offers a second chance company for renters who have a hard time finding a place to rent due to a past eviction or poor credit. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy with the personalized service provided by Alltrade Property Management. Renters appreciate the convenience of having access to documents online. Some also mention valuing the second chance program. Owners share positive experiences, too, with one commenting, "They are taking really good care of my property. The online portal allows for me to review various expenditures, costs etc. and keep a close tab on the overall economics of renting out my property.

Arnold Real Estate Leasing & Property Management

2549 Richmond Road Lexington, KY 40509

Arnold Real Estate Leasing & Property Management specializes in serving the Lexington and Winchester communities by providing rental properties. The company owns all the structures it rents, and both residential and commercial rentals are within the scope of this company. Renters are served by gaining access to listings that are published online, which facilitates the time spent finding a potential apartment or business site. Potential homeowners are also served by this company and have the option to view listings of homes that are for sale in these two communities. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers benefit from the professionalism and experience of the staff at Arnold Real Estate Leasing & Property Management. With memberships to the Lexington and National Apartment Associations, clients can rest assured that the staff always works to provide comfortable, quality housing for their residents.

Baughman Property Management, LLC

1999 Richmond Road, #2A Lexington, KY 40502

Baughman Property Management has been in business in the Lexington area since 2001 and specializes in small rental communities. The company offers pet-friendly apartment homes that are clean and comfortable along with a pet station at each of the company's communities. The company provides access to rental listings so potential tenants can browse for a new home at their leisure. A tenant portal is also provided so renters can manage their accounts, report maintenance issues and contact the company at any time. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are happy with the friendly, professional service provided by the team at Baughman Property Management. They also appreciate how quickly repairs are handled. One happy tenant said, "I highly recommend renting through Baughman Property Management. The rates are very reasonable and the properties are maintained meticulously. Also, whenever I have had issues, Kim has been prompt and helpful. I couldn't recommend this company more!"

Blackburn Property Management

820 Malabu Drive Lexington, KY 40502

Blackburn Property Management specializes in providing one- and two-bedroom apartments near the University of Kentucky and in the Lexington area. The company maintains visually appealing rental units and strives to maintain a competitive pricing structure. Potential tenants are able to look at pictures of Blackburn's rental units on the company website. The company also provides an online payment portal for tenants as an online maintenance request form, so if issues arise in an apartment, it's easy to arrange for its repair. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers find the staff members at Blackburn Property Management friendly and professional. Customers also find the process of renting an apartment from this company convenient. Some other advantages customers gain when doing business with Blackburn include living in the company's well-maintained buildings and gaining access to the well-manicured landscaping on the grounds of each Blackburn property.

Classic Real Estate & Property Management

3118 Custer Drive Lexington, KY 40517

Classic Real Estate & Property Management specializes in property management that ensures tenant comfort and satisfaction while maximizing the property owner's return on investment. It satisfies these tasks by performing maintenance quickly when a tenant reports an issue with a residence. The group also works to accommodate property owners by managing all of the key property management tasks on behalf of owners, such as collecting the rent from tenants and preparing financial records for online access. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers of Classic Real Estate & Property Management appreciate the friendliness of the staff members and the efficiency of the company's maintenance team. One happy rental unit customer said, "I have rented with Classic Realty for many years, and have always had the best service and caring for any situation. They are very prompt with any repairs ever needed."

Coleman Group, LLC

710 East Main Street, Suite 130 Lexington, KY 40502

Coleman Group has been serving the Lexington, Kentucky area since 1997. The company specializes in selling and leasing commercial properties as well as managing residential properties. The maintenance team keeps up both the interior and exterior of the properties. Staff members at Coleman Group also handle the invoicing and collecting rent for property owners. Assistance is provided regarding budgeting to maintain the property as another service for owners. Coleman Group also offers security services to keep tenants safe when in the structures they rent. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Tenants with Coleman Group appreciate the responsiveness of staff members as well as the gentle handling of sensitive issues. Property owners who work with Coleman enjoy the all-inclusive efforts of the team, such as maintaining the property and appealing real estate taxes on the owner's behalf.

Cypress Property Group

270 South Limestone Street Lexington, KY 40508

Cypress Property Group has been in business for over six years, serving the property management needs of the Lexington, Kentucky area. Property types include both residential and commercial, and the property management services offered include maintaining both the grounds and structures. The company provides cleaning services before units are rented. Property owners are offered access to financial records and monthly occupancy statements for record-keeping purposes and potential tenants are able to conveniently view published listings on the Cypress Property Management website. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers benefit from the way Cypress Property Group specializes in representing tenants and property owners while acting as facilitators between the two parties. Customers also find that Cypress Property Group combines local knowledge about real estate with internet access that opens up the market to a broader range of clients. Reviews comment on the "awesome and reliable staff," calling them "very helpful" and "experienced commercial agents in Lexington, KY."

DellaValle Management, Inc.

3151 Beaumont Center Circle, B100 Lexington, KY 40513

For over thirty years, DMI has been a locally-owned leader in the Lexington property management industry. Serving a diverse portfolio of HOAs and private homeowners, DMI offers a time-tested suite of services to minimize the stress of day-to-day management, streamline operations, and provide actionable insight. We offer full-service accounting, administration, and maintenance, all of which are fulfilled in-house by DMI professionals. Our long-term success is emblematic of the trust we’ve built within our community, and that’s the DMI Difference. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

“We would like to commend you and your company employees for a job well-done. The DellaValle Management team did an outstanding job for our community. You are always professional, and handle each request in the proper manner. We highly recommend Glen DellaValle and his staff for any future property management business.” - Garland and Linda Thompson, Residents

Eckman Properties LLC

P. O. Box 2163 Lexington, KY 40588

Eckman Properties has been serving the Lexington area since 2004, providing property management services downtown and near the University of Kentucky. Property owners are alleviated of tasks such as screening tenants and maintaining the properties, and the secure owner's portal provides access to shared documents, financial statements and property updates.. The company handles all aspects of managing the rental homes, which makes it easy for out-of-town property owners to receive an income from their investment properties. Tenants are able to manage their Eckman Properties accounts online, which includes the option to pay through the website and request repairs from the maintenance department ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers find the convenience provided by the staff at Eckman Properties helpful. Property owners also value the option to sell properties directly to Eckman when they no longer want to hold onto the real estate, such as in cases where the property has been inherited and is no longer wanted by family members.

Expert Property Management, LLC

356 Longview Plaza, Suite 140 Lexington, KY 40503

Expert Property Management has been in business since 2009, specializing in managing rental properties. The company takes steps to make it easy for property owners to rent their homes as an alternative to selling. This company screens tenants, handles all communication with renters, collects the rent and enforces issues with the lease when necessary. Expert Property Management handles any maintenance issues, hiring contractors when needed, and performs move-out inspections of each property. The company also manages bill payments for the property owner and provides accounting statements for the owner's records ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers who are property owners value the way Expert Property Management takes care of repairs and manages renters so they don't have to do those things. Tenants also appreciate working with this company, with one sharing, "They are everything you need and more! Quick response time, friendly staff, and professional services. Also the online account...makes it convenient to pay rent and follow updates."

Fayette Property Management

1096 Duval Street, Suite 120 Lexington, KY 40509

Fayette Property Management serves homeowner associations in the Lexington area that want to protect property values of each home as well as entire communities. The company specializes in managing more than one type of community association, including townhome associations, single-family home associations and condominium associations. In addition to setting up meetings for homeowner associations, Fayette Property Management helps with enforcing HOA restrictions. The company also provides a portal where homeowners may pay HOA dues and then provides financial records regarding the transactions. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate the professional, friendly service provided by the team at Fayette Property Management. One satisfied client shares, "We have been very impressed with this Management Company from day one. They have been our HOA Management Company for over 3 years now and still give the same good service as when first hired. Highly recommend."

MLP Management Company, LLC

2828 Easthills Drive Lexington, KY 40517

MLP Management Company has been in business since 1985, providing full-service property management to the Lexington, Kentucky area and all over the state. The company specializes in managing multifamily apartment buildings. In addition to services provided to property owners, MLP Management Company serves tenants by advertising open units online so pictures of the apartments can be viewed at any time. Services provided by this company are geared toward renters, facilitating the process of finding an apartment. Potential tenants are also served by having access to the company's online applications for all the properties managed by MLP Management Company. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers are pleased with the professional, family-like service provided by the team at MLP Management Company. They also value the knowledgeable service and ease of viewing available rentals that are published on the MLP Management Company website. One customer notes, "Very professional, great staff, a pleasure to work with."

Modern Property Management, Inc

1501 Limestone Lexington, KY 40505

Modern Property Management has been serving the property management needs of the Lexington area for over 16 years. It handles properties ranging in size from single-family homes to multifamily apartment buildings as well as HOAs. As a property management agency, Modern Property Management prepares rentals by renovating or remodeling when necessary. The company realizes the importance of keeping income properties fully occupied, so they also handle marketing and thorough tenant screening on behalf of owners. It provides ongoing maintenance of properties and keeps listings published online so potential tenants are able to browse for open rentals at their convenience. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate the way Modern Property Management shares information about properties and screens tenants to avoid vacancies. One property owner said, "(Modern Property's) recruitment, retention and management of tenants have been outstanding. They have the ability to keep me well-informed and recognize when there is the necessity to involve me in the decision making process and when to take care of a problem themselves. In addition, their financial reporting is excellent and provides me with all of the information I need."

PMI Central Kentucky

2050 Regency Road Lexington, KY 40503

PMI Central Kentucky specializes in full-service real estate management, including real estate brokerage and property management. Vacation homes, commercial rentals and homes for rent are listed on the company website to make it easy for renters to browse through the open units. For property owners, PMI offers property marketing and screening of applicants before tenants move in. After tenants are in place, PMI collects the rent, provides financial reports and maintains the property. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers love the professionalism and efficiency of PMI Central Kentucky. They appreciate the way the staff steps in and manages the details on their behalf to keep transactions running smoothly. One customer described their service by mentioning the detailed property management services offered by PMI and saying,"Where do I start????..... Mike (the owner of PMI) has been WONDERFUL to work with."

Positive Property

2440 Mackinwood Drive Lexington, KY 40510

Positive Property has been in business since 1989 and is a full-service real estate company. It specializes in property management. The company provides a hotline that's available 24 hours per day so both property owners and renters can get answers to questions and help with problems without a long delay. Positive Property manages all aspects of renting property on behalf of owners. It also provides internet forms that make it easy for tenants to manage tasks renters commonly need to take care of, such as paying rent or requesting maintenance. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate the thorough service provided by Positive Property. Both tenants and property owners express appreciation for the services, such as maintaining the property and quickly repairing anything that breaks. One customer said, "Living out of state makes managing rental property very challenging. Positive Property handles everything for me from maintenance and marketing to collecting the rent and paying the bills associated with the property. It's definitely worth it!"

Real Property Management Bluegrass

2424 Harrodsburg Road, Suite 101 Lexington, KY 40503

Real Property Management Bluegrass has been serving the property management needs of the Lexington area for over 25 years. Services provided include advertising, rent collection, tenant communication and property updates for owners and facilitating the rental process for tenants. The company provides a way to contact them any time of day or night if a problem arises for either a tenant or property owner. The company screens potential tenants, provides maintenance and manages financial matters on behalf of owners. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers love the professional, efficient service provided by Real Property Management Bluegrass. One satisfied customer said, "Real Property Management...rented out my property in less than a month. The tenants were well screened and both year leases we had worked out great. They completed needed repairs quickly, while being very proactive in communicating with us. They were always easy to get a hold of, and attentive to my questions."

Reliant Property Management & Real Estate

100 John Sutherland Drive, Suite 6 Nicholasville, KY 40356

Reliant Property Management & Real Estate has been serving the property management needs of the Lexington and Nicholasville areas since 2010. The company helps owners find renters and screens them for background troubles that may impact their success as renters. Reliant collects rent, handles all communications with tenants and provides on-call maintenance for after-hours issues. The company also inspects and maintains the property, provides financial record-keeping services for the owners and handles evictions when necessary. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate the friendly service provided by Reliant Property Management. Details mentioned by clients include how easy it is to work with staff members and their helpful service. One customer said, "Reliant was super easy to work with. I was able to set up showings with ease. The agent was extremely friendly and helpful and went out of their way to provide quality assistance.

Rent Lexington Property Management

P. O. Box 24614 Lexington, KY 40524

Rent Lexington Property Management specializes in managing rental properties in the Central Kentucky area. Tenants are able to access information through an online portal, which simplifies tasks such as filing maintenance requests and paying the rent. Services the company provides for property owners include marketing the property and screening tenants. It also manages the collection of rent and preparation of financial records for owners. Property inspections and maintenance are included in the company's offerings. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers appreciate the way Rent Lexington Property Management handles problems that arise and having access to an online portal that can be accessed at any time. One satisfied client described the agent's excellent service, saying, "The Lexington rental market is great, but having Sara and her team taking care of everything from A to Z is what makes this work."

Southcreek Management Company

2365 Harrodsburg Road, Suite B-200 Lexington, KY 40504

Southcreek Management Company has been serving the property management needs of the Lexington, Kentucky area, as well as the rest of the state, for over 40 years. The company specializes in providing a full array of management services for property owners and providing budget-friendly multifamily apartments to tenants. Southcreek handles the clerical renting of a property and also provides the owner with the necessary accounting and maintenance records. It also manages the properties and takes care of maintenance tasks. Southcreek also handles advertising available properties by publishing listings on the company website. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers can appreciate Southcreek Management Company's long history of property management service to the Lexington area. Property owners are helped by the fact that Southcreek takes over all the tasks associated with managing a rental unit.

The Gibson Company

1050 Monarch Street, #200 Lexington, KY 40513

The Gibson Company has been part of the Lexington area since 1991, serving the real estate and property management needs of the community. The company offers tenant representation as well as real estate research and consulting services. Services provided by the Gibson Company include managing commercial rentals and investment properties. Commercial sites include both office units and retail sites. The company's property management team takes care of all aspects of renting properties on behalf of owners, including screening tenants, managing paperwork, maintaining properties and providing accounting services. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers say positive things about the professional service provided by The Gibson Company. Owners value the convenience of the services and often comment on the on team's knowledge and expertise. Tenants appreciate the ease of finding vacant properties to rent by browsing through the listings that are prominently published on the company's website. One customer described the team as a "hardworking group that always keeps their client's best interests at heart."

The Kentucky Life

157 North Limestone, Suite 200 Lexington, KY 40507

The Kentucky Life has been serving the Lexington area for over ten years and is a full-service real estate company. Property management services provided by The Kentucky Life are designed to reduce the stress of renting out a home. The company takes care of all aspects of property management on behalf of property owners. The types of residential properties managed include single-family homes, multi-unit complexes and duplexes. The Kentucky Life also manages commercial rentals, such as retail sites ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers describe the service provided by the personable team at The Kentucky Life as friendly and professional. They are grateful for the prompt response from agents and appreciate the efforts to make constant improvements. One customer said, "We had an issue with plumbing, Adam went above and beyond to make sure it was taken care of! He's very professional and great at following up!

Upscale Properties

1018 East New Circle Road, Suite 204 Lexington, KY 40505

Upscale Properties specializes in property management and rental services in the Lexington area. The company has been in business since 2004. Services are provided by this company for both tenants and property owners. For tenants, the company works to help clients find homes that accommodate their financial needs and budget restrictions. The company also makes it easy for tenants to manage their accounts by providing a tenants portal on the website. Tenants may also request maintenance or notify the company of the intent to move out of a home. For property owners, the company provides full-service management, which is convenient for owners who live out-of-state or who are busy and want to enjoy the property as an investment. ...Read More

What customers are saying:

Customers find the professionalism and personal service provided by the team at Upscale Properties helpful when searching for a new home. A number of tenant reviews note that most issues are fixed promptly, with one stating, "Anytime I have a problem with something that needs to be fixed in my townhouse, they usually fix it in a day or two which is fine with me."