Call to Get Listed
Speak to our team today! Click to call +1 (818) 862-3740

The Best Property Management Companies in Long Island, New York of 2024

The Best Property Management Companies in Long Island, New York of 2024

We considered all 210 Property Management Companies in the Long Island area. We looked at all the data and analyzed these companies on costs, customer rating, reliability, and experience to identify the top 20.

The Best Property Management Companies in Long Island, New York of 2024

Our Selection Criteria

Our goal is to connect property owners with the best property management company to ensure your investments continue to flourish. We scored property management companies on over 30 different variables to provide you a hand-picked list of the best property management companies in the Long Island area.

  • shape-1 210
    Companies Reviewed
  • shape-1 95
    Companies Curated
  • shape-1 20
    Top Picks
  • 1. Reputation

    An extensive track record of reliable, honest service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Understands property laws and industry best practices.

  • 3. Experience

    Knowledge of your property to save you time and money.

  • 4. Professionalism

    Provides transparent, fair pricing and great communication.

The 20 Best Property Management Companies in Long Island

Show Map
A. Michael Tyler Realty Corp
877-641-5900 Click to Call Visit Site

A. Michael Tyler Realty Corp

821 W. Jericho Tpke, Suite 1B, Smithtown, NY 11787

A. Michael Tyler Realty Corp has offered property management and brokerage for over 40 years. The company provides comprehensive property inspection, repair, and emergency response services. The company negotiates with contractors and vendors on behalf of clients. They also offer improvement and operational efficiency plans to help investors streamline their operations and improve their bottom line. The company's team of experienced professionals is available 24/7 to ensure the clients’ property is in top condition and that any issues are promptly addressed. ...Read More

Alexander Wolf & Company, Inc.
516-349-0540 Click to Call Visit Site

Alexander Wolf & Company, Inc.

One Dupont St, Suite 200, Plainview, NY 11803

Alexander Wolf & Company, Inc. is one of the tri-state area’s most experienced property management firms. As part of their property management service, they send monthly financial reports to boards that include vital information such as income, disbursements, and reserve account balances. The organization safeguards its clients’ assets with weekly property inspections and recommendations for improvements and repairs. They communicate with residents regularly, informing them of scheduled maintenance or improvements and legal or community issues. ...Read More

All County Great Bay Property Management
631-446-6600 Click to Call Visit Site

All County Great Bay Property Management

80 Orville Dr, Suite 100, Bohemia, NY 11716

All County Great Bay Property Management is a full-service management company that has been in business for over 20 years. They provide clients with a wide range of services, including rental property evaluation, marketing rental property, placing the right tenant, lease execution, lease enforcement, rent collection, lease renewal, evictions, and more. Every applicant receives a pervasive background and screening report. The company also offers lease execution, lease enforcement, rent collection, evictions, maintenance, inspections, accounting and reporting, and security deposit administration. ...Read More

Einsidler Management, Inc.
631-293-2997 Click to Call Visit Site

Einsidler Management, Inc.

535 Broadhollow Rd, Suite A–15, Melville, NY 11747

Einsidler Management, Inc. is a residential property manager for the Long Island community association. They manage local communities, and their team collaborates closely with board members and other industry specialists to run New York communities ranging from 10 to 1400+ units. The company’s services include maintenance, construction, sales, financial, HUD and LIHTC services, and property management. Budgeting, bookkeeping, payroll, accounts payable, and accounts receivable duties are all included in the financial management for the client’s cooperative, condominium, or homeowner’s association. ...Read More

Essential Property Management
516-868-5224 Click to Call Visit Site

Essential Property Management

775 Brooklyn Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510

Essential property management is a full-service property management company for the cities of Brooklyn, Queens, Nassau, and Suffolk. They can assist you in handling every task required for professional and efficient property management. They know how to thrive in real estate because they have over 25 years of expertise. The company’s management services include commercial property management, condo management services, multifamily property management, and residential property management. The company does marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, property inspection, maintenance, evictions, reporting, and more. ...Read More

FirstService Residential
212-634-5410 Click to Call Visit Site

FirstService Residential

575 5th Ave 9th Fl. New York, NY 10017

FirstService Residential is simplifying property management. We partner with boards, owners, and developers to enhance the value of every property and the life of every resident. Our team of local experts has the expertise and solutions to anticipate your needs and respond – no matter the property type. The size and scale of our company means we can make your budget go further. And our service-first philosophy means we don’t stop until what’s complicated becomes uncomplicated. To make life, simplified. ...Read More

Greenview Properties
631-666-4040 Click to Call Visit Site

Greenview Properties

5 Shore Ln, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Greenview Properties is a full-service property management company specializing in association management, customer service, and financial reporting. The company has over 20 years of experience in property management and development and manages more than 30 communities. Greenview Properties offers a wide range of property management services, including but not limited to HOA management, senior housing management, apartments, and professional and mixed-use. They are committed to sustainable development practices and use the latest technology and equipment to ensure that their projects are completed on time and within budget. ...Read More

Habitat Management LLC
718-316-6300 Click to Call Visit Site

Habitat Management LLC

2626 Jackson Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101

Habitat Management LLC is a full-service property management company specializing in new development, strategic services, and project management. The company also offers its clients commercial lending services, individual unit management, insurance brokerage, and real estate brokerage. Other services include financial reporting, accounting, billing, and collections. The company's individual unit management services include collecting monthly payments, dispatching, and handling repair calls. The company also specializes in selling and leasing residential and commercial properties. The knowledgeable and friendly staff is available 24/7 to answer any questions from clients. ...Read More

JDC Property Management & Concierge
516-800-0090 Click to Call Visit Site

JDC Property Management & Concierge

450 Roosevelt Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

JDC Property Management & Concierge is a group of property managers dedicated to excellence. They are skilled and effective managers with over 25 years of expertise. They handle everything, from massive operations like managing and coordinating home or business renovations to turning on the lights and heating or air conditioning. It provides property management services such as vendor management, housekeeping and cleaning, tenant rental management, and home maintenance and repairs. Concierge services include guest services, vacation management, personal assistance, and more. ...Read More

Long Island Management Services
631-724-2424 Click to Call Visit Site

Long Island Management Services

241 Terryville Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

Long Island Management services (LIMS) is a professional property management company with over 40 years of experience in the business. The company provides clients with a wide range of services, including property management, maintenance, and construction as well as property management services, including administrative management, on-site management, financial services, and reporting. LIMS also provides in-house maintenance services such as lawn and landscape specifications, sprinkler system maintenance, snow removal services, swimming pool maintenance, lifeguards, pond maintenance and backflow devices, and more. ...Read More

Meridian Commercial Management, Inc.
631-732-1616 Click to Call Visit Site

Meridian Commercial Management, Inc.

2410 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville, NY 11738

Meridian Commercial Management, Inc. is operated by two partners, John Kalin and Elliot, who have worked together for 25 years. The company manages commercial and residential property by providing needed repairs and formulating the price of capital improvement products and replacements. The company’s management services include monthly billing, collections plus invoice control, attending monthly board meetings, comprehensive monthly financial reports, and 24/7 emergency response. Meridian Commercial Management’s green initiatives involve energy savings analysis, online service requests, online reporting payments, and more. ...Read More

PMI Gold Coast Properties
631-621-2150 Click to Call Visit Site

PMI Gold Coast Properties

409 Lake Ave, Saint James, NY 11780

PMI Gold Coast Properties is a full-service property management and brokerage company that has been in service for more than 20 years. The company does property management for residential, association, short-term, commercial, brokerage, and estate/executor. The company’s residential management services include free rental analysis, property marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, property maintenance, and financial reporting. PMI Gold Coast Properties provides association management services, including assigning community managers and facilitating meetings. The company also does accounting and reporting, compliance inspection, and maintenance, with 24/7 emergency response. ...Read More

Real Property Management Landmark
516-522-2859 Click to Call Visit Site

Real Property Management Landmark

626 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556

Real Property Management Landmark is Long Island’s leading property management firm, specializing in single-family, multifamily, and mixed-use buildings. With over two decades of experience, they assist portfolio investors to optimize profits while ensuring rental consistency and property safety. They offer full-service property management programs, including rent collection, a 24/7 maintenance call center, online account access, regular inspections, bookkeeping, security deposit management, and more. The company offers additional guarantees to clients, such as an eviction protection plan, a 60-day satisfaction guarantee, a rental guarantee, and house-sitting services. ...Read More

Rental Options Management
866-933-1628 Click to Call Visit Site

Rental Options Management

62 Weeks Ave, Manorville, NY 11949

Rental Options Management provides professional management services that simplify property ownership. They make sure a client’s investment is safe 24/7. They have an owner portal application showing everything from tenant information to leases, notices, payments, and all property accounting. The company has a complete tenant management program that involves dealing with tenant issues, collecting rent, handling maintenance and repairs, and seeking qualified new tenants. The company also has other services, including smart locks, noise monitoring, emergency maintenance, a linen program, availability of virtual walk-throughs, and interior design upon request. ...Read More

StayMarquis
855-589-8728 Click to Call Visit Site

StayMarquis

225 Broadhollow Rd, Suite 405, Melville, NY 11747

StayMarquis is a property management company that takes a modern approach to make property management more transparent and cost-effective. The company’s services include weekly inspections with detailed reporting, reviewing seasonal maintenance checklists, and accessing their preferred vendor network, such as propane, heating oil, landscaping, pool service, and more. The company also offers advisory services on home improvements. They create an inspection checklist tailored to a customer’s property and publish the results of each inspection, including images and discussion, so the client is kept up to date in real time. ...Read More

Touchstone Property Management, LLC
631-448-7919 Click to Call Visit Site

Touchstone Property Management, LLC

16 Sawgrass Dr, Suite #1, Bellport, NY 11713

Touchstone Property Management provides expert property management solutions in New York’s Long Island, Suffolk, and Nassau Counties. The company’s web-based management platform provides innovative capabilities for members of the board and owners to analyze accounts 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. The company is a proud Community Associations Institute (CAI) member. Their trained staff is capable in residential property management, asset management, building systems, property maintenance, and finance and regulatory issues. The company provides comprehensive property management services, including accounting, administration, and facilitating self-managing services. ...Read More

Tritec Real Estate
631-751-0300 Click to Call Visit Site

Tritec Real Estate

45 Research Way, Suite 100, East Setauket, NY 11733

Tritec Real Estate is a family-owned and result-oriented commercial real estate service. With over three decades of experience in the industry, the company has a proven track record of delivering quality projects on time and within budget. They offer a full range of real estate development and construction services, from feasibility studies and site selection to project management and construction. The company’s team of experienced professionals is dedicated to providing clients with the highest service and quality. ...Read More

Vanderbilt Property Management, LLC
516-570-7555 Click to Call Visit Site

Vanderbilt Property Management, LLC

136 Glenwood Rd, Glenwood Landing, NY 11547

Vanderbilt Property Management is a prominent property management firm serving New York, Long Island, and Queens for over 35 years. In addition to daily management, Vanderbilt offers asset management services such as analyzing capital projects and insurance requirements and generating budgets and reports. They provide specialized services ranging from simple accounts receivable to a full range of full-service property management. They can also provide on-site staff, consulting, and brokerage services through their associates. As a boutique firm, they offer a one-of-a-kind approach for your most valuable assets. ...Read More

VNYPM Property Management
718-626-8833 Click to Call Visit Site

VNYPM Property Management

36-30 37th St, Long Island City, NY 11101

VNYPM property management has been managing properties for over 20 years. VNYPM Property management specializes in communication, fiscal management, record-keeping, and consultation. The company's provision and supervision maintenance personnel clean the property's common areas and conduct refuse removal. The company also conducts regular property inspections to ensure that everyone follows the rules and that the property is well-maintained. They also host professional association meetings, which allow their clients to share ideas. The company operates from Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. ...Read More

Wachtler Knopf Equities
516-391-5979 Click to Call Visit Site

Wachtler Knopf Equities

500 Bi-County Blvd, Suite 230, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Wachtler Knopf Equities LLC, situated in Farmingdale, New York, was founded in 2005. It is one of the fastest-growing property management and leasing firms on Long Island’s outskirts. WK Equities, led by knowledgeable, experienced real estate managers, manages the commercial office and industrial buildings on behalf of some of the nation’s most well-known investors. The company is currently in charge of eight buildings totaling over 750,000 square feet in some of Long Island’s most desirable corporate markets, including Melville, Farmingdale, Bethpage, and Plainview. ...Read More

Worth Real Estate Brokerage & Management
516-489-1341 Click to Call Visit Site

Worth Real Estate Brokerage & Management

2 Bellmore Rd, East Meadow, NY 11554

Worth Real Estate has been serving the tri-state region for over 50 years and is a family-owned business. The firm specializes in construction, landlord representation, development, tenant relationships, property management, contract services, and real estate transactions. The firm manages over 3 million square feet of property in New York City, Long Island, and New Jersey. The company’s services include revenue enhancement, accounting, reporting, property consulting, contract services, lease signing, pre-development consulting, 24-hours emergency response, coop property management, tenant relations, and more. ...Read More

Property Management in Nearby Cities